Blog
Art and Value
Posted on 7/31/2011 4:43:05 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art Business | The Working Artist | Thoughts on Art

Streetlights
Perhaps this is just a sign of the current economic times, but lately there seem to be a lot of articles and blogs about the value of art. Artists no doubt feel threatened when their livelihood is called into question by politicians who want to cut government spending on the arts even though those cuts would not affect most of the artists directly anyway. Yet artists are up in arms because ART is being threatened, and in a sense diminished, and they by extension as well. That is understandable. Artists do have a way of holding themselves above the rest of the world because they are doing something important and creative. At the same time, many artists are stumped about valuing their own work in monetary terms. Some feel they should be supported by society for their creative contributions to it even when their creations will have very limited airing in terms of audience. Some feel that they should be paid equivalent to other celebrity figures be they in entertainment or sports (another form of entertainment). Of course, one can easily argue that athletes raise enormous sums for the team owners just as movie stars do for their studios or musicians do for their record companies. It seems reasonable they should be paid large amounts for their efforts. Artists, generally, are in it for themselves only, although many will protest that they are giving so much of value to everyone. Part of the problem for artists is that everyone isn’t interested.
I don’t mean to sound cynical here because I often harbor many elitist thoughts myself as an artist, but I also look at the historical trends in the arts and see that a lot of assumptions have been made by artists in the modern world that were not made in the ancient world. If we look at past cultures, especially the high cultures like ancient Egypt, Persia, Greece, or Rome, we’ll see many examples of wonderful art. This art, however, was commissioned by the few primarily for the pleasure of the few. The grand monuments of many civilizations were built by slaves or craftsmen whose lives were literally in the hands of the masters. Many of those grand monuments were enormous displays of hubris often intended to subdue the masses and intimidate enemies. The smaller scale finely crafted items of precious metals or stones were definitely in the hands of the few and never even seen by the many. Later cultures usually see those arts and artifacts out of context where they may be contemplated at leisure in some museum display or book about the culture from which they came.
Closer to our own time when painting became a separate object instead of a painted wall or religious backdrop, there was already a mindset among the wealthy elite of collecting those finely crafted things. In fact, that collecting impulse is one reason so many early examples of art are now so widely dispersed around the world instead of still residing in the countries where they were created. The wealthy plundered the past in the name of the state or in the name of their religion.
Some might protest here that cultures other than the biggest and wealthiest also produced art, just not on the same scale. I don’t deny that, but the art we see in these societies, although some is quite expressive, is generally utilitarian in purpose. If it is venerated at all within the culture, it is done so when the object is of some spiritual significance. Many of those island cultures, tribal cultures, or aboriginal cultures were not materialistic in the way that most modern cultures are, and certainly not like the gold-crazed explorers of the 15th and 16th centuries, those often referred to as the early “robber barons.” Interestingly, it was during the 15th and 16th centuries when such enormous strides were made in painting and sculpture in Europe. Painters began to be valued in ways they had not been before, and some of them became fairly wealthy and respected members of society. Very few achieved reasonable success, which is why there are so few in each generation that are widely known, at least by name, among those whose knowledge of art history is limited – Michelangelo, Titian, Rembrandt, and so on. Velasquez, Hals, Goya and others are certainly known to art students but much less so to the public at large.
When art moves from the service of the state or the church, its value hinges primarily on how it is venerated within the culture, i.e., on how it is marketed. Connoisseurs of art arose in the 14th and 15th centuries among the aristocracies first and then spread to the newly rich, the wealthy merchant class. Just as other commodities were valued for craftsmanship, uniqueness, and singular quality – fabrics, furniture, wines, and so on – art also began to be judged by qualities inherent to its manufacture. Academies were established to control the education of artists, critics arose to define the beautiful, and aesthetic principles were codified that initially were based on the art of the past. Painters skilled or lucky enough to be patronized by royalty spent their careers painting for the court. In more egalitarian societies like Holland, wealthy merchants became the patrons of artists like Rembrandt and Vermeer.
Social upheaval in Europe, wars and civil wars, affected the arts and their perceived value. Artists became dependent first on recognition by the academy. Some artists moved in social circles that previously would have been beyond their station. Benjamin West literally moved from colonial America to England and became, essentially, an English artist with aristocratic pretensions. Very much the same thing happened to John Singleton Copley who also succumbed to the influence of the English Academy. To a great degree, changes in art and its appreciation follow the various social upheavals as artists gradually move from pleasing the social upper crust to observing it, to in some cases criticizing it, to ignoring it for the vernacular, bourgeois, and sometimes even the underbelly of society – permissible, for example, in 19th century France but not in that of 18th century France, at least not until after the revolution there.
Shifts of power in Europe, first in France and later in England, the burgeoning new democracy in America, ultimately lead to even greater changes as a result of mechanization and the Industrial Revolution. Traditional lower classes are presented with new opportunities some of which probably contribute to social strains that affect twentieth century events like both world wars. Artists during this long period of change tend to become more fractured, some continuing to follow the traditional path established by the academies and others exploring new ideas and ways of expressing change that is sometimes described as revolutionary. It’s almost as though artists generally become split personalities. On the one hand there is the longing to belong, to be appreciated, to be compensated and on the other hand to be aloof, to maintain an artistic distance, and even to scoff at some of the trappings of society.
It is my belief that each artist today wrestles either consciously or unconsciously with this dilemma of acceptance or aloofness. There is wide latitude, of course, how any individual may respond to this challenge, but I do believe that it affects the decisions that artists make in pricing their work and in how they present themselves to the public at large. I understand that the overview given above is very truncated and makes no specific reference to the individual circumstance of any particular artist. This already has been done in many biographies of artists as diverse as Ingres, Watteau, Whistler, Monet, Picasso, or Warhol. Among those recognizable names of artists who achieved some measure of success are many that did not always bear that success well. For some, success ultimately led to their demise. We see this still today in celebrities who succumb to the pressures of notoriety. So, what is the value of art? How an artist answers this question will be reflected in more than just a price tag on a painting.
Leave a Comment