Blog
Trick or Treat
Posted on 10/31/2011 4:30:12 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Early Evening
Today is Halloween, and despite all the would-be ghouls and goblins in search of various treats, I’m not really concerned about the holiday per se. Thematically, though, it does suggest a few thoughts that do relate to the practices of making and appreciating art. I have many good memories of Halloween from childhood. Neighborhood kids were rarely accompanied by parents as they trekked door to door in search of various treats. Several friends and I frequently roamed many miles that covered several neighborhoods before we loaded shopping bags full of candies. Up until the sixth or seventh grade, we always went in costume – disguise gave one boldness. Later the costume was reduced to a mask, and eventually to a stocking head like we were preparing for a bank heist.
Events at school during elementary years were always exciting as well. The designated Room Mothers did fantastic jobs of transforming the school into a great Halloween fair. There were all kinds of games and contests where prizes could be won. Popcorn, cotton candy, candied apples, great varieties of baked goods aptly decorated with black cats or pumpkins were offered as prizes or for purchase. Many classrooms became haunted rooms, game rooms, rooms for telling ghost stories, and some just for relaxing and enjoying the many treats.
The holiday was quite an event until something shifted within the culture. Stories about ghouls and goblins gave way to stories about kids being kidnapped, poisoned or maimed by tainted treats or hidden razor blades. Molestation and real-life horror made parents increasingly protective and worried. The idyllic times that I knew as a kid, including the freedom to roam night or day over most of our town, disappeared. This saddens me now as I see the limitations that most kids experience within their neighborhoods today. Paradoxically, other freedoms, illicit freedoms like sexual, drug or alcohol experimentation, have become more widespread.
You may be wondering by now how this relates to the making of art or its appreciation. My thoughts concern a broad perspective that considers the history of art in several cultures and periods. Any view of art history will be somewhat skewed by the available information and by the taste of the viewer. We can think of the great civilizations of the past where art served both religious expression and the power of the state. From our present day perspective, we can admire the scale of monuments, the beauty of various art forms, and the skill of craftsmanship accomplished without the sophisticated tools on which we have become dependent. If that were our only consideration, though, we would miss several important ideas. One is that art was often used to exert power over others. Rulers used it to keep their minions and conquests in line – the purpose behind many grand monuments. The beauty and grandeur was meant for the few rather than the many. Quite a lot of the art with which we are familiar was never seen by the public at large. This was true in Egypt, Mesopotamia, China and much of the Orient, and to some extent even in Greece and Rome.
As each of these civilizations declined, so did their artistic expression. Decadence that crept into the social fabric also was expressed in art. One has to look hard to find this work today, for it is not readily displayed before the public. Certain themes, however, like the brutality of war, appear in most civilizations to represent the subjugation of enemies. This, unfortunately, appears to be universal. I used to think that civilization as a whole made steady progress from its beginnings to present time. However, now I think more in terms of fits and starts, redundancy and repetition of mistakes and misjudgments. Technologically, perhaps we can see an upward trend, but ethically and morally the movement is not so clear. What I experienced as a sense of freedom as a child may have been only the limitation of my understanding of the world, the narrowness of my childish focus.
Art of the early civilizations, particularly Classical Greek art, strongly influenced Western Art especially during the Renaissance. Christianity also exerted strong influence, and for a time we see a parallel development of Humanistic and Christian artistic expressions, sometimes separate and sometimes blended. Humanistic treatment of form, for example, is directly translated into Christian themes. The two traditions also set the stage for generations of conflicting ideology. The brilliant painter Caravaggio, who advanced painterly form dramatically and gave us some of the most inspired depictions of Christian theology, was also a hedonist and exemplified the depraved humanist tradition as seen from a Christian perspective. It is as though the ghouls and goblins depicted by the earlier Hieronymus Bosch were manifest in the world and not just in the mind of this other brilliant early Renaissance painter.
Humanism is not simply or even necessarily depraved. Neither should we say that Christianity is the reason or cause for superstition. The flights of imagination that sometimes carry one into realms of phantasms and phantoms can actually come from either tradition. The individual given over to irrationality is the source of fear and depravity. Sometimes art attempts to deal with this theme especially as we move closer to modern times. The convergence and divergence of Humanism and Christianism (to include all form of Christian belief) I see as a thread weaving through much art from the time of Christ forward.
Since most art now is created by individuals rather than societies, even though societies can exert strong influences on individuals, I also believe that art has to be seen within the context of the individual in terms of that person’s motivations and intentions. The power of the church or the state to influence the direction of art is far less today within most western countries than in the past. As a result, it will take a very long lens to sort out the trends and to identify what will last into the distant future as a definitive expression of a particular time and place. The tricks of perspective (of one’s philosophical stance) can emphatically affect one’s enjoyment of the artistic treats available for consumption. No mask is required though we often choose to don one.
Leave a Comment