Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

The Best Advice

Posted on 11/3/2011 3:09:54 PM
By Donald Fox
3 Comments

Houston Street
Houston Street

            What is the best advice you’ve ever been given about your painting? Nowadays, access to information certainly is not an issue for anyone who wants to learn something about the painting process. Online there are blogs galore, videos on YouTube, advice columns, book and DVD offerings, websites that cater to artists, and so much information that to call this the information age surely is an understatement. Reruns of several of the TV painters, deceased ones at that, are easily found on many public television stations. Quite a few artists, budding and experienced, attend workshops and demos or take classes again and again. Locally, even walking into an art supply store, I encounter instructional videos playing in a corner or someone giving a demonstration of the latest medium enhancement. Advice is everywhere.

            Having chosen to educate myself by following a traditional academic path for undergraduate and graduate degrees (I have one of those so-called “terminal degrees” in Fine Arts), I don’t disparage that experience, neither do I especially recommend it to others. I do grow a bit impatient at all of the criticism that sometimes flies around the art school higher education programs. With any educational program – traditional academic, apprenticeship, self-directed – the outcome depends on the input. Overall my experience in art school was a positive one, but maybe that’s because I went into it with the attitude that I was going to get the most out of it. In any case, the whole of my many years in education taught me first and foremost how to learn. I know how to research a topic. I know how to apply critical thinking and evaluate information for its veracity and value.

            As expected, of course, along the way in my educational journey (one that continues and will continue for as long as I am able to do so), I was subjected to reams of advice, some of it noteworthy and some of it useless. Several people and what they said do stand out in my mind, and to these individuals I offer thanks every day. One in particular I’d like to mention here. He was a professor of painting who taught students how to develop their skills by focusing on their unique abilities. His gift was his ability to draw out of students the strengths that they had not yet discovered for themselves. While some professors were autocratic and overtly critical, Professor Barker was supportive, kind, and a probing inquisitor but in the most relaxed and non-threatening way.

            We talked often about painting and teaching even when he was not one of my regular instructors. Once I complained that I felt frustrated in not improving.  I thought that I had reached a plateau and certain things were not working in my paintings. He suggested a simple technique that in effect helped me improve my critical eye. “Keep everything,” he told me. Periodically I should pull out older work and do a self-critique. I should compare several pieces from several months apart. Look for what is working. Look for the parts that I really feel drawn to and think are accomplishing something. In the older work, especially, I won’t remember all the things I was caught up in thinking about while painting. I’ll easily see the good passages and can compare those to more recent work. The important thing is to recognize that I did those parts of the paintings just as I did those parts that are less successful. I have the skill. I just need to work on consistency.

            We worked through this process together several times. He’d suggest that I bring in three or four paintings that spanned several months. Then he’d have me tell him what was working and how one compared with another. I discovered that I could see more than I thought when I was expected to verbalize to him what I saw. In effect, he was teaching me how to learn from myself. For me this has been a life-long lesson that has also applied to other circumstances beyond painting.

            All of us are offered advice about many things. As the saying goes from AA to Weight Watchers, “take what you need and leave the rest.” With painting, what is your best advice? What has made a difference for you?


Comments

3 Responses to The Best Advice

Just this week, I've experienced the very power of 'keeping everything' for a review later to demonstrate one's growth. I began painting in earnest about six years ago now when I retired. My own thought then was to do little other than paint, paint, paint and, to do a whole lot of it! And so, that's what I did. I didn't keep track of what I had done, I didn't slow down to assemble a website, I didn't enter many competitions, etc., etc. I PAINTED.

Three days ago however, I decided that my storage area, where I have built appropriate cribs for canvas storage, was over-flowing and needed a good cleaning and culling. In that six years, to my own amazement, I've completed about 70 works that hang on my own walls and those of family and approximately twice that many that I've stored in this storage space.

Seeing all of these within the very short timeframe of these three days has indeed lifted me up. I do now realize that I have grown and matured. My works now are actually quite a departure from those very earliest ones. In some cases, I can say, "thank goodness" but in other instances, I can see where I have left something behind: some essence of spontaneity and a certain 'crispness' that I had at the onset.

And so, I do most totally agree with your comments and the power of looking over one's shoulder once in awhile.

Keep painting,

John

Great article and really something to think about. I too have gotten good and bad advice over the years. As an art major in college, my professors varied in skill in art and teaching ability. Some were great artists and bad teachers, others the opposite and some were poor all the way around. I had one professor who told me I had no talent and should change my major. Being 19 years old, this was devastating as he didn't say this in a caring, for my own good kind of way. Despite this, I kept plugging away and avoided this professor for future classes. I went on after college to educate myself through workshops of artists that I admire. I have one teacher/friend that calls me his best student. Talk about feeling pride. One bit of advice he gave was to keep a file of artists and their work that you really like... decide why you like it and how you would want to use it in your own work. Also, keep a file of artists work that you don't like... figure out why you don't like it (this is harder than you might think) and try to NOT do that in your work. Finally, if you are wanting a career in art, to the public you are only as good as your worst piece. In other words, just because you created it doesn't mean you need to slap a frame on it and put it in a show. Make sure you are proud of your accomplishment because if people see an array in the quality of your work, they are most likely to conclude that you aren't that good, but get lucky every once in a while. Great article, Donald.

Thanks, John, for your comments. I appreciate your story of your own process.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post