Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Judging and Judgment

Posted on 11/7/2011 8:52:46 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Skimming the Surface
Skimming the Surface

            In most of the major spiritual traditions, followers are taught not to judge others. The downside is that by judging one is setting one’s self in a superior position to another. Logically this makes no sense since in the eye of the creator we are all alleged to be equal. In societal terms, however, an ingrained order tends to call on one to judge others by their actions and by their acceptance of their place within the structure of the society. When one transgresses against social strictures, punishment often follows. The offender is redeemed by the punishment and brought into alignment with the established order. This, in any case, is the theoretical basis.

            Children are taught by their parents to adhere to certain principles and act accordingly. As they internalize the accepted modes of behavior, they begin to monitor their actions as they grow and are deemed mature when their judgment enables them to function according to expectations. Judgment of right and wrong, of success and failure, or of benefits and detriments becomes the norm. Many who follow a spiritual path see no contradiction between the spiritual admonition against judgment and the social expectation to exercise judgment on a regular basis. As a result, numerous justifications and explications attempt to rationalize the temporal and spiritual worlds.

            Many artists speak of the practice of art as a form of spiritual expression. They see their creative activity as a way of celebrating life, as a form of meditation or prayer, or as a way of affirming their and others’ connection to the whole of creation. I would count myself among them even though I may not necessarily agree with their interpretation of spirituality. One can’t be all things to all people. The exercise of judgment, from my perspective, is necessary in order for there to be the best expression of creative ideas. Rarely are artworks manifested full blown. There is a long and sometimes arduous process for works to come to fruition.

            The artist relies on a range of skills through which inspiration or insight is molded into a work of art. These skills are accumulated over a period of time through much practice and constant feedback. Just like the growing child is guided by the parent, the nascent artist is guided by a mentor until the necessary understanding is internalized so that the artist may become his own critic and judge. This requires thousands of judgments and self-critiques in order to develop to a level of independent operation. The goal is continuous improvement even when this sometimes invites comparison with the work of others. Perhaps this is the biggest challenge for the artist, for the ego can be a daunting foe. It can lead one forward or lead one astray. The molding of the artist is not always synonymous with the molding of character. However, when approached with humility and openness of mind, the practice of art can be a discipline that molds character as do other forms of spiritual practice.  


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post