Blog
Art and Music
Posted on 4/17/2014
By Donald Fox
2 Comments
Topics: Aesthetics | Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art History | Art in nature | Language | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art

“Art constantly aspires towards the condition of music,” so wrote English art critic Walter Pater in Studies in the History of the Renaissance: The School of Giorgione. The obvious question here is what is the “condition of music”? Many answers may follow just as there would be many interpretations of a poem, a painting, or any other work of art. Some say that music is just what it is – tonal sounds placed in rhythmical context and that have no reference to anything else. This suggests something a bit like abstract painting if we substitute color and shape for sound. So is the implication here that all art moves towards the abstract? Viewed from a modern perspective, that might seem to be the case.
Pater was a proponent of the idea that all experience comes from sensation and that there is constant flux in the world of our experience. Sound, as in music, is pure sensation. Since art generally appeals to the senses first, whatever else it may do by expressing through image or symbol or language, it “aspires” (to maintain the personification) to the purely sensual. Sensation may be thought of as concrete experience, but the initial sensory response is, in a way, abstract since it has no context or meaning until it is interpreted by the brain and thus becomes perception. Humans, being curious by nature, also feel compelled to find meaning or to give meaning when there appears to be none.
With most western painting from the Renaissance well into the nineteenth century, pictures represented the external world as experienced by the artist. Through suggestion, color, shape, symbol, and narrative, artists expressed ideas, stories, or concepts in these paintings. There often was specific emotional and intellectual content. Music, by contrast, may have been created for specific occasions and appreciated on intellectual or emotional levels, but typically it did not have a specific message or meaning. As one might say today, “It is what it is.” Music is abstract in that sense. It is experienced as pure sound. Any meaning derived from it is by association only and these originate in the listener.
Renaissance painters became quite adept at designing their paintings with classical or spiritual content by using symbols and visual metaphors to express their ideas. Yet there simultaneously existed the abstract qualities of the pictures that viewers could respond to without understanding any symbolic visual language: bright colors and harmonies, sensual shapes, and rhythmical patterns from the interplay of line, texture, light-dark contrast, and proportions. Similar abstract qualities can be seen in primitive and aboriginal art as well. Whether the conscious move by artists to focus primarily on these basic elements was inevitable or not is hard to say. In hindsight this certainly seems to be the case or at least might be argued by some art historians. It is important to remember, however, that since Pater died in 1894, he could not have been thinking about abstract painting as it later came to be. He might have known the Post Impressionists, but would have known none of the early modernists.
Another idea that Pater expressed is that art is best understood in the context of its time. Certainly we tend to re-evaluate works from our own perspective, but this is for our own purposes and not for the creators as we may impose concepts that would have been incomprehensible to them. The appreciation of art history requires diligence and knowledge for understanding. Pater’s observation about art and music might seem prescient to our ears, but it too should be considered within the context of his particular focus on Renaissance painting.
2 Responses to Art and Music
Leave a Comment