Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Neither a Borrower...

Posted on 6/11/2014
By Donald Fox
Comment on this
Topics: Appreciating Art | Art and Culture | Art Business | Art History | Art in nature | Drawing | Language | Learning about Art | Metaphor | Thoughts on Art | Ethics 


            When I was in junior high school, I completed an assignment for English class that required a narrative. I had read a comic book story that I found interesting about a Japanese-American soldier who although treated badly by his fellow American soldiers nevertheless saves the live of several of them in combat. This changes their attitude toward him. No longer do they see him as a Jap. He is now their American buddy that happens to be Asian. This would have been in the late fifties, so the idea was pretty radical at that time regarding race and discrimination.

            I borrowed the plot, changed some of the action sequences, characters’ names, and created new dialog. With new description also, I think I made a pretty credible story. My English teacher liked it and asked me to read it to the class. Most of my classmates liked the story too. I had no idea at the time that I had created a piece of appropriation art. Neither did I understand anything about copyright issues or plagiarism. Still, what I wrote was a credible reinvention of something else I had read from a different medium.

            I think about that story every time I hear something about an artist getting into trouble for potential copyright violation or appropriating images or ideas from other artists. There are many examples, of course, of artwork that has been reimagined. Picasso did this a number of times with the work of Velasquez and other artists. The new works in one of Picasso’s many styles are significantly different from the original. There is no question about the source nor is there any question about the new work being a copy – derivative, yes, but not copied – reinterpreted is a better word. Peter Paul Rubens did drawings after Leonardo, and in at least one instance, Rubens’ work is all that we know of Leonardo’s since the original has been destroyed. Both Rubens and Picasso were making homages to earlier masters.

            The question of copyright infringement is a sticky one, particularly when money is involved and no credit is given to the original creator. Certain instances are obvious violations especially when something is copied outright. I always caution students against making paintings from photographs unless the photos are ones they have taken themselves. One might copy a painting as part of the learning process – there’s certainly a long tradition of doing just that – but those works shouldn’t be displayed or sold. But, can you borrow an idea or incorporate a collaged element into a work? Many artists have done just that without gaining permission.

            The law says what it says and artists should be aware of it (easy to find online). English teachers tell students to avoid plagiarism by saying to them, “When in doubt, cite.” In other words, always give credit to the source.  Republication requires permission from the copyright holder, and that is a separate issue from plagiarism. Perhaps the wise advice for the artist who may be thinking of copying or appropriating would be, “When in doubt, don’t do it.” That way you can’t go wrong.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post