Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog

Idle Thoughts


            Many people in a variety of disciplines are faced with the problem of having to do something they know can be done better in a different way, but they are bound by the constraints of policy, procedure, or demand that it be done according to orders. This might sound like the military, and that is certainly one place where constraints are often applied, but this could just as easily be in a customer service environment or in a medical facility. Experienced personnel often are not consulted when policy changes are to be introduced, and so bizarre elements can be included that no one likes. Everyone gets grumpy and badmouths management. Employee moral suffers. Older institutions exhibit this behavior the most. Anyone who has been in public education or worked for the government knows what I mean.

            One would think that creativity would trump the entrenched, but this is not the case. Even institutions that are founded on creative principles eventually succumb to the calcification of time-honored procedures. A good example is the art academy that had its origins during the Renaissance. The initial idea was to strengthen the prestige of artists, promote craftsmanship, and incorporate many innovations of artistic technique into the training of artists. This seemed to work well for several hundred years. Eventually, the system became too cumbersome and resistant to new ways of thinking. Younger artists with creative ideas not in keeping with standard practice were cowed into compliance, tried to reform the system, or left the institution altogether. This did not only begin with the impressionist movement in France. Older painters like Corot, Courbet, and Manet either skirted or challenged the system, which may have raised them in the eyes of younger artists but created some issue with traditional ones.

            The college and university system of art education in this country has not replaced the academy, but it has acted as a sort of stand-in. Many schools have promoted modernist approaches over traditional ones. As a result, standards of quality have declined somewhat although it could be argued that creativity has flourished. That is, if one believes that creativity is defined by continually making things new and different.

            The curriculum promoted by these schools overall has tended to support the larger art marketplace that was once dominated by Paris and eventually was replaced by New York City. For a time California entered into the mix in painting but mostly with the craft movement. Whether any new ideas in art since the turn of the twentieth century have lasting value remains to be seen. One hundred years of recent modernism doesn’t always compare favorably to five hundred years of academic traditions in spite of its sometime overstatement and other shortcomings (too many rules, stifling of experimentation, and other complaints lodged against it).

            Artists continually make creative choices, and they go their own way or align themselves with like-minded thinkers. Science sometimes plods along too, but it has a modus operandi in the scientific method that can sort out disagreement by identifying paths of most effective searching and questioning. It’s not one hundred percent objective – nothing is really – but it can more easily bypass the subjective confusions that often dog the arts. The academy and other educational approaches to the arts have attempted to deal with the balance between upholding a tradition and promoting new exploration. The tendency to adhere to bias in one direction or the other is tempting for the hard questions are avoided. One just toes the party line with the blinders of the unquestioning adherent. Ambiguity can be unsettling. Choosing the strict interpretation, however, may ultimately affect creative output. New ideas and new directions require risk, and risk is always uncertain. In human endeavors, though, very little is ever certain, for it seems our lot to keep asking questions.

Related Posts


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post