Donald Fox Fine Art
© 2020

Blog


Posted on 10/1/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Within the United States this is a time of insidious political intrigue. Government officials are supposed to be representatives of the people, but in truth they serve their own political ambitions. Politics has become a money game, and those most adept at playing that game get to stay in office most of the time. With the country roughly divided between conservatives and liberals, we end up with a government that is barely functional at best and often, like now, not functional at all. The irony is that both sides claim democratic virtues, integrity, and claim to have the people’s interests at heart. In truth they only learn to frame issues so that the other side is blamed for dysfunction. They appeal to their base, but hopefully, one might wonder, the people will realize that both sides are simply gaming the system. As long as big money is at stake, neither side can be trusted to do the right thing. There is too much concern with power rather than substance.

            Sometimes I worry about the art world as well. Much of what is fed to artists by way of advice has more to do with making money than with making good art. The artist, in effect, becomes a brush for hire, but this is what used to distinguish fine art from commercial art. The latter was in business to make money and the former to make art. There were assumptions embedded in both sides of the equation. On the commercial side, the artist was seen as a skilled artisan hired to do a specific job. The response might be creative only insofar as the product met the specifications of the client. On the fine art side, the artist created his or her own work from personal choice free of dictates from a boss, an overseer, or a demanding client.  The artist called the shots.

            Even within the realm of fine art, though, there has always been the carrot of making it big. For some artists, that might mean compromising a principle here or there. The gallery might say, this is what sells, so give us more of this. So, the artist might do more of that thing in order to make the sale. The absurdity of this was dramatized in Woody Allen’s film Hannah and Her Sisters. The artist lover of the younger sister is brought a rock star client by Hannah’s husband who is the musician’s accountant. His purpose is to impress the younger sister whom he lusts after. The artist is insulted by the musician’s insistence on “something really big” as opposed to something of particular quality. The artist erupts in anger and insists that he doesn’t sell work by the yard. He gets to play the part of the purist, and is a kind of stand-in for Allen who has skirted the edge of the Hollywood system by being his own writer, director, and producer.

            Artists have always been supported in some manner whether by the state, the court, the church, or by patrons. Art has been a commodity of sorts for about the same length of time. The growth of a middle class may have democratized and commercialized art more than any other factor as the means for creating art became more widely available beyond the relative few that could attain the court positions or favor of the church. The more money that has come into the mix the more artistic integrity has been challenged. Some artists have been pulled into the mainstream and some have remained on the outskirts. Can we say today that the artist has more choice in this matter? Perhaps. Unless we think of ourselves as victims of circumstance, a pretty weak position in my opinion, the choice of direction is always there before us.

Posted on 9/30/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Digital photography has made many aspects of image recordkeeping for artists quite simpler. In the past we had to have good quality color photographs, slides, and transparencies, the latter for any reasonable quality reproduction in print. All of this could become quite expensive and require a lot of space for storing duplicates. With the quality of digital cameras continuously improving, many artists can photograph their own work and get reproduction quality images that are easily kept as digital files. These can be made to pretty much any size digital fie with a basic photo program in the computer. From these an artist can create CD-ROMs to send image portfolios to galleries or collectors, enter contests, or keep backup file copies. The savings in expense and space quickly returns any investment in camera, photo program, or computer, all of which are tax deductible expenses as well.

            One additional advantage of having good digital files is the opportunity to review work on a regular basis, even work that has been sold, may be out on loan, or is physically unavailable for any other reason. Personally, I also like to document the progression of most paintings after each painting session. I can study the image at a particular stage, zoom in on specific areas, and make decisions about what to do next. With my photo program, I can also flip the image to see it in reverse or flip it top to bottom, which sometimes enables me to see any compositional errors more easily. For large paintings, especially, seeing the image at smaller scale it allows more accurate assessment of the total composition. Some artists may still use a reducing glass while painting, but that can create some distortion and it’s best viewed with one eye (like looking through a telescope).

            Personally, unlike some other prognosticators, I don’t think photography will ever replace painting. It has been over a hundred years now, and though photography has made unimaginable leaps forward in technology and format, painting continues to thrive as a vital form of artistic expression. New materials may be developed, but painting itself will likely not change appreciably except in terms of imagery as has been the case over the past six hundred years or so. This is an exciting time to be a painter, and digital photography serves as a valuable tool for the painter to track, chronicle, and study his or her work on a continuing basis.

Posted on 9/29/2013 6:13:30 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            When executing a process, usually it is necessary to proceed step by step in the proper order, make sure every step is complete before going to the next, and be careful to not leave anything out. Upon completion, something has been made, a place has been found, or something works that before did not. Some processes, though, are more flexible, or we could say, more forgiving. The process of making art, for example, will certainly involve a variety of steps, but the steps do not have to always follow a particular order. The experienced artist will likely change some things around to create variety and keep the challenge interesting.

            In oil painting, there is the dictum of fat over lean. To ensure that the finished painting is structurally strong, the wise artist will begin painting thinly, typically allowing each layer to dry before applying the next, and gradually thicken the paint as the painting sessions increase over time. The thicker (fat) paint will always go on top of thinner (lean) paint that is dry. This avoids the problem that can develop with underneath layers that are inadequately dry pulling away from surface layers because of continued shrinkage of the underlying paint. Many painters, however, paint wet into wet, which allows for more manipulation of the surface and more blending of layers into one another. Essentially everything will dry at the same rate, so the problem with layered paint is avoided.

            Students often ask what part should be painted first, but unless they’ve done at least some painting, they might think that each part is completed before the next part is done – kind of like paint-by-numbers. With proper guidance, they can learn that paintings proceed from general to particular. Large, simplified areas are blocked in first and only gradually are specific areas refined for what might be considered detail. Even following this simple guideline, however, an artist could vary the approach depending on which part of the painting is actually painted first, how much refinement is done, and how much adjustment is made from the first application of color. Every student needs to work through the process numerous times to get the sense of how the paint works, to begin to understand the challenges of color mixing, and to begin to personalize the process to what works best for that person. This takes patience, some amount of humility, and the sense that it is okay to fail.

            A lot can be learned by studying a wide range of art from different time periods. The end product, of course, often covers up the stages of development, but one could exercise the imagination and question how the artist might have proceeded. There also is written evidence that some artists have left behind about their working process. This can be very interesting, but it is also important to realize that some artists are known for experimentation. Their process may vary more than that of others. Additionally, some artists have very complex processes that include many painting sessions wherein complex applications of color and complex techniques are employed to create certain effects that may become a kind of signature for the artist.

            Ultimately, the best place for the student is in front of an easel, brush in hand, and tackling the next painting and the next and the next.

Posted on 9/28/2013 5:31:53 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Currently I’m online with tech support, and the technician has remote control of the desktop. I see the cursor moving around the screen, windows appear, the cursor moves across text, the screen disappears and another appears, numbers are deleted and new numbers added – if one task doesn’t work, another is attempted. In some ways this process probably mimics our brain functions while in the process of actively creating. The intuitive, inspired part of the brain is sending out active signals, making associations, and envisioning possibilities. The reasoning, application-oriented part is implementing actions, making adjustments, testing ideas, and ensuring that certain procedures are followed. Sometimes we may be in a state of hyper-awareness and feel as though we can actually watch ourselves think and do at the same time. Much of the time we just do things prompted by activity that functions below the level of conscious awareness. Whichever mode is in operation, there remain complex hidden components that keep the whole system running at peak efficiency. All we need do is tune in and respond appropriately when certain messages flicker across the screen of consciousness in order to see the amazing results that our mind-body-spirit processor manifests for us.

Posted on 9/27/2013 6:30:17 PM
By Donald Fox
2 Comments


            There are many gifts in life, and perhaps the greatest is life itself. There are so many gifts that it is easy to become oblivious to the most obvious because we get focused on needs, desires, and wishes, many of which are insignificant beyond the momentary indulgence. Our mobility, the use of our senses, and our ability to think and reason and appreciate become so readily a part of who we are as individuals that quite often we take for granted, or maybe just forget momentarily, the magnificence of these life expressions. Fortunately, we also have many other gifts that remind us of everything that is to be appreciated. Nature in all its glory is one of these gifts. We are part of nature and finely attuned to it, and as such we are able to experience the many manifestations of it and communicate these things to others through our words, our art, and our understanding. Through the contemplation of nature, we are reminded of the beauty, grandeur, and majesty that are around us and within us every moment of every day.

            About three years ago, a stray cat gave birth to a litter of kittens beneath a storage shed in our backyard. For several months may wife and I would catch sight of one or more of the kittens, but they always scurried away before we could get anywhere near them. We managed to gain the trust of the mom, and through her we slowly were able to tame the kittens. One of the three males died suddenly less than a year after his birth. The vet thought he got into some poison, maybe some radiator fluid from the car shop that is behind our house. The others, including the sole female, a tortoise shell tabby, have thrived along with the mother. We named her Savannah and marveled at the extreme care she took in teaching her babies the limits of the yard, how to properly use the yard as a toilet, and how to avoid the many dogs that sometimes run loose in the neighborhood.

            Savannah flourished in her new home. In spite of her slight handicap of having only one good eye, the other was covered in scar tissue from some previous injury, she doted on her babies and defended them fearlessly against dogs many times her size. We already had a cat when we met her, but it seemed right to take her and her brood in. She had brought us the gift of life and love, and her natural wisdom chose the best place for her family’s new home. Later we installed a pet door, and all of them learned to use it within a relatively short time. It was also a great joy to see her grow from a malnourished young mom into a healthy, vibrant cat that found her long-forgotten kittenhood in the safety of her new surroundings.

            Last year we lost our original cat to a long debilitating disease. She was fifteen and very dear to our hearts. Savannah seemed to know our sorrow, and she had a knack for showing up when one or the other of us would be feeling down. It was with great shock and sadness that this morning as we were driving off to the park that we found Savannah collapsed in a neighbor’s front yard several houses down the street. She apparently had been hit by a car sometime late last night. She had been in for dinner early last evening, and we wondered why we hadn’t seen her first thing this morning as usual. It’s doubly sad because she was always so wary of the street. I remember watching her teach her kittens about the limits of the yard. She would walk the length of the yard with the kittens on the curb and she at the edge of the street. She would not let them get off the curb. She walked them from our yard to the neighbor’s yard and back again several times. It was obvious that she was showing them where it was safe.

            Savannah has been a great blessing in our lives. She brought us a new family of cats each remarkable in its own way, and she gave us the gift of her love for three years. We will miss her, but we are thankful that her offspring are here to carry on her memory. The gift of an animal’s love and friendship is one of the greatest gifts that nature can bestow. I am thankful to recognize and acknowledge that gift and to give back whenever I can.

Posted on 9/26/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


For some, Paul Cézanne’s work is an acquired taste. There are apparent distortions in his drawing, his colors can sometimes seem flat or sometimes a bit garish, and the brushwork may feel a bit heavy-handed. Similar things are often said about Picasso and other painters considered artists difficult to understand or comprehend. Preceding Cézanne there are several hundred years of polished, highly refined realism that arguably could be said by the 19th century had become staid and formulaic. Many of the Impressionists felt this was true and to some degree broke from the tradition, at least stylistically. Their subject matter remained in the newer tradition of genre painting and representation of life around them. No biblical subjects and no history paintings come under the Impressionist banner.

            Cézanne worked plein air, but his landscapes look and feel very structured as opposed to the more casual appearance of Impressionism (with the interesting exception of some Pissarro landscapes, but then Pissarro was something of a mentor to Cézanne, and Pissarro’s work might generally be considered less radical than the younger Impressionists). Cézanne also did a lot of studio painting where he could labor and study for extended periods of time his own process of observation. He admired the work of Chardin and Rembrandt and saw himself in a line of painters concerned with the substance of painting rather than simply using painting to illustrate. As a result, his work acts like a bridge between traditional realism and the subsequent interest in abstraction begun to be explored by artists like Picasso and Braque.

            Cézanne also wrote about his work, and from his notes we know of his awareness concerning planes in space, the importance of viewpoint, and the underlying geometry of many forms in nature. He was a careful observe, but his observations did not lead to a mimetic form of interpreting of the world around him. He was interested in how structural form could be rendered on canvas. This led to his famous statement that all nature could be seen in the geometry of the cylinder, sphere, and cone. Also, rather than those fleeting effects that Impressionists were so enamored of, Cézanne focused on the physical solidity of objects.

            I always enjoy Cézanne’s work for its strength and sometimes surprising solutions. He reminds me that uniqueness of vision can be a strength in itself, and that observation is about more than noting surface detail. He was very bold for his time, and he worked long and hard to "make of Impressionism something solid and durable, like the art of the museums.”

Posted on 9/25/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            One interesting idea concerning color in landscape that a teacher suggested to me many years ago is that as objects move into the distance, they are represented by removing the yellow from the paint mixture. I’ve seen this concept repeated in books and even referenced in some demonstrations. The simple logic is that yellow is among the warmest colors and has a tendency to advance within the picture plane. The opposite idea is that cool colors like blues and blue-purples tend to recede or appear to move into the distance. These are fundamental principles of color theory, but to think of taking yellow out of a mixture is a novel idea. Since mixtures consist of adding colors rather than taking them away (how could you possibly do that anyway?), the twist in thinking makes the idea stick because the student has to grasp what is being said.

            Using the landscape as a sample subject works perfectly because of all the green that frequently is part of the scene. Green obviously is composed of blue and yellow. If one removes yellow from green, what is left is blue, one of the coolest colors. What the student is being told, then, is that distant greens appear blue because there is little to no yellow apparent in them. On the other hand, experienced painters will also know that there can be cool yellows and warm yellows as well as bright and dull ones. They will also observe in some outdoor settings that distant objects may have a yellowish tint, but that particular yellow has been cooled down by the addition of purple or blue so that it actually is a greenish or purplish yellow. Delicate amounts of blue or purple, whichever is appropriate, can be added to a cooler yellow to adjust it to the proper hue.

            This will only truly make sense to the student as that student develops a more accurate eye for color. I can’t say how many times I’ve heard a student say, “I don’t see what you see.” When asked whether they like the result that’s illustrated, they might reply, “Yes, I see that it works, but I never would have guessed to add what you did.” That’s because they’re not yet thinking about observed color.  They’re still stuck in generic color mode: sky is blue, grass is green, and so on.  

            Some will struggle with basic color concepts for a longer period of time than others might. It’s always satisfying and exciting to see the light come on and to see a student begin to use color principles to represent observed phenomena. It’s almost as though their paintings take a different turn overnight, though for some it’s a very long night.

Posted on 9/24/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Jacques Barzun was a French-born American writer and philosopher who wrote about education and culture. The latter years of his life he lived and worked in San Antonio, Texas. He wrote extensively about education and was a teacher of teachers. He also wrote widely about culture, notably about music, literature, and art. In the late fifties, in his now classic book The House of Intellect, Barzun wrote: “Art distills sensation and embodies it with enhanced meaning in memorable form – or else it is not art.” There is a lot said in this relatively brief sentence. As Barzun himself said later about much contemporary art the lack of meaning reduces its effectiveness. Or, as is often said in Texas, it’s “all hat and no cattle.”

            Being an artist, I often question what I see that falls under that generic banner whether it is presented with a capital “A” or a lower case “a.” Perhaps there is a bit of risk for a practicing artist to judge the work of others, biblical exhortations in mind, lest there be backlash or criticism that one is being too egocentric, too narrowly focused, or too petty. Reading the work of professional critics, however, many artists will readily agree that artists are probably better suited for criticism than the critic, for the artist is the daily practitioner of the art and knows it from the inside. Critics have a tendency to overinflate and follow their own agenda.

            Still, even among artists there are those that apply their craft as a tool to convey a message, to create “enhanced meaning in memorable form” as Barzun has noted. There also are those that simply make beautiful objects, pretty but shallow. This is not to imply either that art is only about the message, but if there is no real message, then there is no real art. The two, form and message, ideally blend into a whole and we get something greater than the sum of the parts. One could argue about conscious intention versus intuitive expression and suggest that the artist may not always be aware of the message that is conveyed. That may be fair enough. Art does not follow the logic of science, neither is art by its nature less substantial simply because it manifests sometimes in inexplicable ways.

            The scientist may look at a tree and describe its features, the process of its life cycle, and how it fits into the ecosystem within which it exists. Everything is measurable, verifiable, and to a degree predictable. The artist may sense the tree as a living relative and see its symbolic value. It represents transformation in its seasonal shifts, renewal and rebirth every spring, and serves as a bridge between earth and heaven, deeply rooted while also reaching into the ethers. Its image calls forth these associations. From this kind of connection, artists create other images that do similar things; they remind us of who we are and how we’re connected at the most elemental of levels. The scientist observes sensation and quantifies it. The artist refines sensation into unique form and creates new meaning from it. This meaningful form is what we call art, which is in a sense the world re-envisioned through the artist’s eyes.

Posted on 9/23/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            This week, September 22-28, is Banned Books Week. The choice to prevent people from reading certain books is nothing short of censorship. It is one of the worst infringements of personal liberty, which is why the framers of the U.S. Constitution made freedom of speech and freedom of the press among the first of the Bill of Rights. According to the American Library Association website, “Banned Books Week is an annual event celebrating the freedom to read. Typically held during the last week of September, it highlights the value of free and open access to information. Banned Books Week brings together the entire book community –- librarians, booksellers, publishers, journalists, teachers, and readers of all types –- in shared support of the freedom to seek and to express ideas, even those some consider unorthodox or unpopular.”

            Those that choose to ban books, regardless of motivation, join the ranks of some of the most despicable dictators and autocrats of history all of whom banned books, censored speech, and openly destroyed information with which they did not agree including a lot of artistic expression. They, the despots, recognized the power of ideas and that a freely thinking populace would reject their narrow-minded and restrictive focus. Therefore they attempted to eliminate any expression of disagreement through instilling censorship.

            The saying that knowledge is power is far more than a cliché. Knowledge comes from challenging concepts that sometimes may be at odds with long held beliefs. In a free society, we understand the importance of that freedom of choice: either to read or not to read. If something is considered personally offensive, we can choose not to read it or not to look at it. We can teach our children to question, to be discerning, and to think critically about what they may encounter. We don’t, however, ban or censor because that is against the principles in which we believe so strongly. This is also one of the biggest challenges many of us face when we may question the integrity or truth of material with which we disagree or think unsuitable for others. We want to protect our children and those we may assess as being more sensitive or vulnerable. Because, however, we have free speech, we can challenge those erroneous beliefs and ideas and show their flaws in logic or their offensive nature. We do not have to ban them, but we can undermine them and reduce their influence.

            Artists are among those that historically have suffered from censorship. Perhaps this is because many have typically been at odds with the social order of which they were a part (or sometimes held themselves aloof from). Perhaps it is because they represent thinking differently from the norm. Perhaps it is because some artists have been outspoken critics of a society or regime. Probably it is a combination of factors, but from a certain perspective, this places a moral burden on the artist as a protector of free speech and free expression. To wield that moral authority effectively, the artist must hold to high principles of integrity and truth. Whether those are upheld, of course, is then judged by the audience to whom the artist speaks.  

            Frankly, censorship will not endure, for ultimately it will bring down the perpetrator. The desire for freedom is too strong although how we actually define freedom is another issue entirely. For more information about Banned Books Week or to find some of the books, an amazingly surprising list, that have been banned in the past, go to:

http://www.ala.org/bbooks/bannedbooksweek

http://www.bannedbooksweek.org/

Posted on 9/22/2013 6:22:24 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Yesterday my wife and I took a friend from North Carolina to MFAH to the closing day of James Turrell’s exhibit The Light Inside.  The show was heavily attended, so there were lines to get into several of the exhibition rooms and in two of the most popular ones the time inside was limited. During the run of the exhibit, anyone could spend as long as desired in any of the rooms since not as many people were attempting access at the same time.

            Opening days for many major exhibits are often filled with viewers there as much for the social occasion as to see the art. With the exception of rare shows like Impressionist work or works from large private collections that are infrequently shown, anyone can visit during the week and not have to contend with hoards of people. Those blockbuster shows are often ticketed and timed entry so that even when there are consistent streams of viewers, the galleries tend not to be overly crowded. Closing day, of course, is often similar to opening day. Those that had put off coming mingle with those that want one last look.

            Turrell’s work focuses on light, and many of the pieces are small room environments where the light is carefully controlled either by projection onto a wall or into a corner or the piece is a construction illuminated from the inside. In fact, many of Turrell’s pieces made reference to the Quaker concept of the light inside, the internal spark of spirit and divinity. Also, with other pieces, Turrell suggests going to meet the light.

            Turrell began his study of light some forty years ago while a student of experimental psychology. His personal experience with light took on new meaning when he also became a pilot. I can understand this since my dad was a commercial airline pilot, and I grew up around airplanes and airports. Though I never became a licensed pilot, I have flown and flown in dozens of aircraft from two-seaters to jumbo jets. I well understand the experience of light above the clouds as viewed from a cockpit. A sunrise or sunset seen from thousands of feet up in the air is far more spectacular than one seen from on the ground. There are also perceptual effects up there that one doesn’t experience at ground level.

            Turrell’s fascination with light has been translated into a body of work that creates unique visual experiences for the viewer. He has developed ways of singling out the light to create light environments. Some of these works use natural light and some use artificial light. The ones using natural light are often called portals and create a viewing experience by framing the light with an opening so that the viewer can contemplate the light itself. Imagine being in a cavern and observing the light seen through the entrance as it changes. Some of these pieces remind me of my own observations years ago when I worked in an unheated warehouse. The corrugated sheet metal building had small holes and gaps between wall and ceiling through which sunlight would shine in certain times of the day. These shafts of light would slowly move as the sun changed position. This affected the illumination inside the warehouse which was poorly lit by artificial light. I found it interesting to contemplate the moving shafts of light and to follow the illuminated shapes as they moved across the floor or over various objects. This gave me a unique understanding of earth’s rotation relative to the sun since that is really what we experience rather than the sun’s movement across the sky.

            Light is fundamental to our vision. Without light, we can see nothing. It is a strange experience to be in a totally dark space. Many never actually experience that; for them there is always some ambient light around. In a flotation tank and in sleep labs, both of which I’ve experienced, there is absolutely no light. That kind of experience makes one aware of background illumination that we experience even in the desert when there is no artificial light within miles, but there is light from the stars. Certainly as a painter I appreciate light, and I appreciate artists like Turrell who give us reminders of what we can know as well as experiences that lead us in new directions.

Posted on 9/21/2013 3:35:45 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Timing is important in most of the performing arts. Obviously, music needs to have all musicians playing at the same tempo so that instrumental sound is coordinated or that a singer’s voice coincides with the instrumentation. Rhythm is part of what makes that happen. Also, in dance there is coordination of movement with music as well as one dancer with another. Visual and sound elements are blended together into a careful orchestration. Film and theater also rely on timing of one character’s interaction with another, of the characters’ interactions with the setting, and when there is musical accompaniment, just as in dance, the timing between sound and action is critical to successful expression. Even in architecture timing is a critical element, for the various stages of construction depend on a cast of characters doing individual jobs: materials must be delivered to the worksite, certain crews that are dependent on others must wait until parts are complete before they can add whatever their contribution may be, and then there will be clean-up after all construction is complete. Timing is an important element in many forms of expression, and it must be perfected for there to be success.

            For the visual artist, timing is also important although there is often more leeway and flexibility. A watercolorist must sometimes work quickly to make maximum use of paper or previously painted areas remaining wet while new color is added. Some parts must dry completely before subsequent layers can be added. Marvelous effects can be created or ruined if the timing is rushed or delayed. Oil painters can work directly (wet into wet) or indirectly (layering or glazing), and the timing for each technique will vary, again depending on the desired result. For both kinds of painters, this kind of timing is related to the actual process of painting.

            Painters also deal with timing in a different way. Those that work from nature are to some degree tied to seasonal changes if they keep their work relevant to the actual time of year when certain subjects are done. One could paint a snow scene in the summer or a beach scene in the winter, but the painter would be working from memory, drawings, or reference photographs. To some degree this may also happen with studio work based on field studies, but the memory of the experience outdoors is still fresh and not from six months earlier.

            In a much larger sense, timing also may affect an artist’s specific output. Early in a career an artist may not have the skill or experience to tackle certain subjects. Some may develop slowly over time, or the artist may specifically devote time to study and practice techniques before actually using them in a painting. Experience and maturation come with time, and generally these cannot be rushed. Timing may also affect when and where work might be exhibited. Some artists start this process too soon, and that works to their detriment. More energy is put into putting together exhibitions than in creating the work to be exhibited. Why show work that is not the best that can be achieved?

            Timing is an important consideration in most artistic expression, either in the process of making it or in the timing of when it may come into being. Part of an artist’s development is dependent on timing as well, and it would be wise for an artist to contemplate this idea from time to time.

Posted on 9/20/2013 8:25:26 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            I like to think of a painting as an exploration. I usually have a pretty strong concept when I do begin a painting, but I understand that the process will take me in directions that I may not foresee at the outset. I would never just copy a scene or a photograph. There is little creativity in slavish copies. Rather, a subject is what some call reference material. It can give information about relationships among colors, shapes, and intervals, and particularly how the light may be affecting whatever is being illuminated. This is all information that needs to be translated into the medium of paint but also interpreted in relation to how I (or any other painter) may be responding to the scene. I explore the scene and the painting as it develops for what to me are the most interesting elements.

            Obviously there are many ways to make paintings, and artists do tend to respond to things quite differently. Their thinking processes are different, their likes and dislikes are different, their sense of what is important is different, and how they interpret what they see is also different. This is a good thing, for we, as viewers, are given a wide range of artistic responses in the form of the created work. Ultimately this broadens our perspective of the creative experience, also a good thing.

            An abstract approach to painting may have spontaneity as the underlying impetus. The painters’ response may be improvisational, much like what we might encounter in jazz music. Another artist may experiment and then create a variation on that experiment. Pretty soon there is a series of works that interrelate and develop a theme that might even inspire more variations at a later time. Whether there is more freedom in abstract work is a debatable point that could be argued from either side. Probably most of us think of realistic painting as being less free and certainly not so improvisational. Plein air artists might disagree, but there’s still the matter of the subject; something is being observed and painted.

            Too many general statements about painting can be misleading. It’s better to look at individual work and assess what any particular artist is doing, what his or her motivation is, what the purpose and intentions are, and what overall aesthetic informs that artist’s work. We always need to come back to the work, for that is where the expression either succeeds or does not. Painters do change over time, at least the best ones do. Since I tend to think of painting as an exploration process, I tend to favor those painters that show me evidence of their exploration in the finished work. I don’t discount everything else; however, I judge according to what is given. To do less than that is not fair to the artist.

Posted on 9/19/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Unlike some technologies art has a way of moving slowly over time. Granted one could say that computer generated graphics is a giant technological leap forward if we place their printed images in the realm of printmaking, but computer paint programs are not at all comparable to easel painting. The art of painting has changed imagery many times in the last 100 years, but painters essentially employ the same techniques that were developed hundreds of years ago even when doing abstract work. It is also true that there have been developments in paints (synthetic pigments, acrylics, or water compatible oil paints, for example), and brushes are manufactured slightly differently than in the past, and acrylic gessoed canvas is probably the most popular ground, but the painting process itself is little changed.

            Sculpture and architecture may be the two areas of art that have changed the most primarily because of the development of new materials and subsequent alterations in the process of making those materials either required or made possible for the first time. Many years ago a sculpture professor I knew said that the greatest impact in sculpture and ceramics were usually made by artists that either developed new materials or developed a new technique. Just one example would be artists utilizing paper pulp as a sculptural and painting medium rather than using it to make sheets of paper to be drawn or painted upon. Collage and mixed media are relatively new forms of artistic expression though each may have a lengthy decorative application historically.

            For rapidity of change, however, the younger arts of photography and film take the prize. Photography has moved from plates to film to digital imaging in just over a hundred years. The increasing sophistication of cameras and lenses have fueled the mechanical side while development in film and darkroom techniques still attract some photographers though digital photographers tend to refer to them as dinosaurs. Digital has definitely waged a successful revolution. Just witness the steady rise in megapixel resolution. In film, we moved from black and white to color, to wide screen and cinemascope and then to letterbox, I-Max and now 3-D has made a resurgence. Video has opened other avenues of exploration. Wherever there’s a technology that can be accessed, artists are there to capitalize on its possibilities. Even so, new does not always mean better. In spite of new technologies, many artists are still exploring traditional media and techniques quite successfully while adapting them to the present.

Posted on 9/18/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            In my painting class today a student asked me how she could be freer in her painting approach. She doesn’t like her habit of trying to be as detailed as possible as quickly as possible. She had sketched out her landscape working over a warm-toned ground as I had previously suggested as a way to begin a landscape painting. I had also done previous demos of different subjects and expressed my preference for using a toned ground so that I’m not painting against white, which makes it more challenging to see values accurately.

            She also had blocked in areas of color but had not established a pattern of darks and lights. She asked me to show her what I would do next, so I worked blues into the distant trees, placed related but darker blues into foreground shadows, and added intermediate tones into the middle ground. She said that she didn’t see those colors in her reference photo. I explained, as I had before, that we aren’t concerned with copying. We’re constructing a painting, and we want to establish clear spatial zones, which we can easily do with color and value. Shadows in general tend to be cool – thus the blue. If we can establish a clear range of values with one color throughout, then it becomes easier to add other colors of similar value into appropriate areas. Providing sound logic was an attempt to appeal to her propensity for detail, which comes from a rational, logical way of perceiving.

            Experienced painters often feel comfortable with ambiguity and with adjusting their painting process as they go. They key in less on particular elements within a scene and focus more on what’s happening on the paint surface. They sense, if they don’t verbally ask, questions like these: Is this too dark or light? Do I need more color here, tone down a color there? Is this part too harsh or drawing too much attention to itself? Their visual thinking frequently blends with kinesthetic response, and they often by-pass verbal explanations altogether.

            Many students need programmed steps to follow until they feel confident enough to experiment on their own. Why not work with blue or purple in the shadows instead of always reaching for black or brown? The color will be richer overall, and those blues can be easily toned down if necessary. They may even be largely painted out although their effect may continue. That effect will never be felt if they’re not added in the first place.

            Most representational painting is a combination of observation and imagination. Slavery to observation results only in copying. The subject provides visual information, but the artist’s imagination infuses a painting with interesting possibility. A writer can write a story that is said to be richly detailed and can virtually place the reader in that setting by making him or her believe the reality of it. The story, however, is a fiction. The characters don’t exist anymore than the place even though both may bear strong resemblance to reality. Paintings often picture things in a similar way.

            We, as viewers, should never take the painting as reality (of what they represent) any more than we would the story. Both are simply forms of art that utilize aspects of reality, which are shaped to the intention of the artist. An alternative way of thinking about this is that the artist is creating a new reality as expressed in the work of art. My student grasped the concept behind what I was telling and showing her, but it will take her awhile to assimilate that into her own work.  I encouraged her to do a series of small paintings executed quickly without attempting any detail. If she will do this on a small scale, she will grasp more quickly how the process can work for her at a larger size.

Posted on 9/17/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            “Green is the color of the sparkling corn…” I remember those lightweight lyrics from a pleasant little Donovan song years ago. Green has always seemed such a vibrant color, alive and at times sparkling as the song suggests. It carries the peacefulness of blue with that color’s heavy influence, but its yellow additive gives a liveliness that blue frequently lacks. In paintings, though, green can quickly become rather clichéd and somewhat stale, mainly because it is used in such direct and unimaginative ways. Many students get stuck using only tube greens – usually viridian or permanent green light, possibly chrome green, or the ubiquitous sap green. Rarely do students venture into mixing their own greens, but if they do make this shift, they begin to find many varieties of greens right out of a simple palette.

            Beginning with either a warm or cool blue plus the admixture of a warm or cool yellow, students quickly see that greens are directly affected by the initial choice of components. For bright greens, choose cerulean blue plus cadmium yellow, and for slightly duller greens, substitute ultramarine blue. As with most any other color, lightening with white also tends to slightly dull greens too. It is easy to push either of these green mixtures much duller and warmer by adding red or brown beginning with small amounts to see subtle changes. The more red or brown that goes into the mixture, the duller and less like green the mixture gets. This is a simple experiment with complementary cross-mixing. The brown serves as a substitute for a dark red. Any of these dulled mixtures can produce lovely tints by adding white.

            A more adventurous route can be developed from mixtures of black and yellow, essentially what the old masters often did. These very muted colors are quite soft and can appear somewhat flat especially starting from a tube black. Mixed blacks might give more interesting results. Either way the mixtures will be subtle and not likely to be used in plein air painting unless the sky is quite overcast. Still, the pleasure of discovery from experimenting with these types of mixtures can help train the eye and the mind of the novice painter. Many plein air painters tend to work with a limited palette anyway, often with just red, yellow, and blue plus white. Their practiced eye enables them to create a range of useful greens through adjacent and complementary mixtures.

            One mistake to avoid is to start relying on formulas for color mixing, especially greens. Initially the more time that can be spent on the palette and noting the results, the faster one’s ability to successfully handle colors will progress. Making graduated color charts is another good activity, for this forces the painter to observe and create regular steps up or down in value to create consistent changes from one color tone to the next. Don’t be afraid to experiment, but also don’t just work haphazardly. The point is to develop a skill and to hone the eye to perceive color accurately. Greens might be challenging, but positive results are very rewarding.

Posted on 9/16/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            In recent blogs I’ve mentioned more than once that students often complain about history. They find it boring and difficult because of all the names and dates associated with it. A fan of baseball or football or basketball, however, will have no difficulty in citing players, statistics, game scores, or championships over a number of years. General history, however, is boring. Maybe, like me, some of these students had high school history classes taught by coaches. Some of these teachers might have simply read out of the textbook or used class time for students to do assigned reading. There was no attempt to make the history come to life in the form of people’s stories. Note that the word story is part of the word history.

            Scholars that write the history books gather historical information mostly by doing primary research. This is sometimes referred to as field research. A biologist will go out into the field to observe and study animals in their natural habitat to best understand how the animals live their lives. Good historians do something similar. They interview people who have experienced significant events if those people are still living. They collect oral histories when they can. They study original documents like letters, newspaper articles, business documents, photographs, or anything that can give some insight into the lives of people at a particular time. All of this constitutes primary research. Anything based on what other historians have written is considered secondary, and some of that may prove useful in some instances when primary research documents are unavailable.

            Libraries are important for housing not only books but also some of these primary documents. This is one reason that presidential libraries are such a big topic after a president leaves office. The new library will house thousands of documents and photographs, news reports and videos relating to the presidency. This will yield years of research for future historians.

            Recently a “new” painting by Vincent van Gogh was definitively attributed to him. The painting is from a private collection, and years ago the painting was not able to be authenticated – in fact it was called a fake. The disappointed collector put the work away since it was deemed to have little value. Recently, though, someone recognized a specific structure in one corner of the painting and was able to identify the place that was pictured. Scholars returned to van Gogh’s letters and found a passage in a letter to Theo van Gogh that described the painting. Further study found the painting listed in a catalog created after van Gogh’s death. X-ray spectral analysis also helped identify pigments used by van Gogh in other paintings as well as the kind of canvas on which he worked. This combination of primary research techniques has clearly proved the painting as authentic. History has its uses, and in this particular case has made for an intriguing detective story.

            It is sad that the embarrassment felt by the novice collector when told that he had bought a fake will not be erased even though he has been vindicated after his death. He will never know the triumph of having found and owned an original by one of history’s most popular painters. Other scholars are berating themselves for not taking the time twenty years ago to reexamine the painting when they had the opportunity. The few small glitches that effectively removed this work from the public eye now serve as part of a larger historical narrative that has made worldwide headlines. No doubt others have been prompted to rummage through their attics in search of historical treasure.

Posted on 9/15/2013 5:03:29 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            The late American writer John Updike studied art as a young man after he had graduated from Harvard with a degree in English. It was with writing, though, that he would make his mark, and he is one of few American writers to win the Pulitzer Prize multiple times. Throughout his writing career, he also maintained a connection to the art world primarily as an art critic and wrote extensively for the New York Review of Books where I used to read his learned reviews. In 1989 he published a collection of writing on art titled Just Looking. Again in 2005 he published a collection of writing from the New York Review of Books, this time titled Still Looking. All of these essays focus on American art and are as enjoyable to read as they are thoughtful, insightful, and educational. It is obvious that Updike truly loved the art that he wrote about.

             His fictional writing often focused on middle class America in a sharply observed and richly detailed style of realism that could easily be compared to the many realist painters that made up the bulk of American art well into the twentieth century. Perhaps Updike is at his best as an art appreciator (and art critic) when he writes about artists like Eakins or Homer or Whistler. Interestingly, he connects many early American modernists like Arthur Dove and Marsden Hartley and later Jackson Pollock as solidly part of the American expression of realism with its concern for the direct experience of the material world. Many of these early abstract artists were well trained in representational art and allowed their interest in abstraction to grow from that experience. Even Pollock was strongly connected to material in his struggle to find a means of expressing his restless interest in experimentation. In the end, it is not the image, representational or abstract, that holds sway but the process of bringing something into being.

            Pollock is credited for his action painting, for releasing the canvas from the easel, and sometimes even credited with inventing performance art. Many of his early paintings are rather clumsily executed, and, in my mind, feel somewhat forced to a conclusion. At the height of his drip technique, the giant canvasses create a kind of cosmic expression that other abstractionists seemed to strive for but rarely achieved. Painting that emphasizes action, however, only leaves the record of that energetic expression. The painting itself remains static and can presumably only be reanimated within the mind of the viewer. The image can be impressive but needs to be seen in real life and not some tiny image in a book or on a screen.

            Monet’s grand late life water lily series equal in scale almost anything done by modernist abstract painters. The subtlety, density, and complexity of surface also rival that of modernist painters. He accomplished this while using nature as his guide. Was it the French joie de vivre that led to Impressionism’s triumph? Was it the American hard boiled sense of manifest destiny that led to the irrepressible search for new territory to conquer?

Posted on 9/14/2013 6:19:32 PM
By Donald Fox
3 Comments


            I love cats. They’re interesting, intriguing, graceful, and beautiful creatures that like many denizens of nature, including humans, can exhibit traits that can be seen as not necessarily positive and sometimes scary. Also, like most creatures, if not treated well, cats can become disturbed and ill-adjusted. By default it sometimes seems, although we know it’s through a series of momentary choices over time, my wife and I have fostered dozens of cats – we’ve rescued them from hostile environments, had them spayed or neutered, and found homes for them or adopted them to become part of our own family.

            I hate to think of an animal being destroyed simply because it lives free of human contact. These days we find many humans living on the edge or in the shadows of civilization, and we don’t euthanize them. What? We can’t equate a human life to that of a dumb animal? Well, aren’t there a lot of dumb humans? Certainly there are humans that act like animals, or worse.

            We tend to think of ourselves as special. After all, we’re the creatures made in God’s image – or so we keep telling ourselves. We are the ones that have built civilizations, conquered others, and established dominion over the earth even to the point of fouling the nests we’ve created. That is our birthright, isn’t it? The only problem is we may end up making our world uninhabitable except for those most prolific and enduring of creatures, cockroaches and rats. They don’t concern themselves with art or religion or politics. They simply survive.

            Scientists study the flora and fauna of the planet in order to understand how life works. They often see in broader nature and societies in the wild, behavior that is strikingly human-like. They also see behavior that is as compassionate and loving as any human expressions. Yes, sometimes in nature the rule is kill or be killed, eat or be eaten. One entity serves another in the larger web of life. Just because one is higher up the food chain, that is no reason or justification for wanton destruction. Within a relatively short time, a species would do itself in from eliminating its own food bank. Humans, however, have great wisdom and foresight. They can intervene and countermand the basic principles of life and do a better job by making everything more efficient and productive. Right.

            Cats don’t do this though. They exist according to their nature. They don’t try to rise above it or amend it. Perhaps if we learned from our observations of nature that the system works perfectly well when left to its natural order, then we could make our art, love our planet, and till the garden without destroying it in the process.

 

Posted on 9/13/2013 7:19:10 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Lead in paint and in drinking water is a known health hazard. Although lead was removed from commercial paints some years ago, there still are buildings and houses and probably some toys that have old paint layers that contain lead. Also, some plumbing still contains lead, which is the main way that minute particles of lead may leach into drinking water. It is still possible to find lead white sold in art supply stores, but many paint brands of artist’s paints now sport a lead-free label on the tubes. This is all good, but lead is not the only toxic ingredient to be found in artist’s paints.

            There are a number of heavy metals used to make art pigments. These are highly toxic if ingested and could cause cancer or other very serious health problems. Obviously paints are not made to eat, but our skin is a permeable membrane, and the cosmetics industry has made a fortune selling products that are designed to be absorbed through the skin. Even some medicines are now given trans-dermally. Some cosmetologists say that what goes on the skin goes into the body. This has led to all manner of natural products that have largely eliminated many toxic chemicals. If caution is being exercised within the skin and beauty industry, artists would be wise to also take care with the chemicals they use on a daily basis.

            The wise artist should first learn about the materials with which he or she works. Information on the chemistry of paints is widely available online and in a variety of books. Most paint manufacturers will provide safety data sheets on the paints that they make if they are asked. These sheets are required by law for facilities where workers may come into contact with hazardous materials. Forewarned is forearmed, as they say. There is no reason for undue alarm here because with a bit of good common sense artists can work safely with any of the materials currently available on the market.

            First, always have good ventilation in the studio. If you have particularly sensitive skin, wear protective gloves. Most art supply stores sell thin latex-free disposable gloves for artists. If using spray paint or spray varnish, wear a protective mask and eyewear. Either avoid eating and drinking while painting or take special care not to get paints or solvents near the food or drink. Always wash hands thoroughly after a painting session or before handling food. Don’t hold brushes in your mouth even if you’re very careful about keeping the handles free of paint. Use a brush soap or regular soap for washing hands; it’s a good idea not to use any solvent for cleaning paint off skin.

            Most modern homes have a wide array of potentially dangerous chemicals in the bathroom and the kitchen. Many cleaning products can be hazardous. The common sense care anyone would take using any of these products is no more or less extreme than the care one should take using artist’s materials. There is no cause for alarm, but there is wisdom in being careful and staying safe.

Posted on 9/12/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            German filmmaker Werner Herzog has created an interesting and wide-ranging body of work with feature length fictional and documentary films as well as short films in both formats. Often his stories focus on characters that have exotic, if not impossible dreams, and deal with themes of challenge, adversity, and a kind of triumph through failure. His friend Les Blank made the documentary film Burden of Dreams based on Herzog’s challenges in the Amazon jungle while filming Fitzcarraldo about an eccentric man who planned to build an opera house deep in the jungle so that he could bring his hero Enrico Caruso there to perform. Critics compared Herzog’s dogged behavior in making Fitzcarraldo with that of the title character’s determination to persevere over incredible odds. Ultimately Herzog was successful unlike his film character, but the director faced seemingly insurmountable delays, funding problems, changes in actors, death threats from natives, and the vicissitudes of the jungle. The latter he referred to as a brutal, erotic, seductive, and inhospitable place filled with fecund life and the constant challenge of death.

            In Burden of Dreams Herzog speaks about the dreams of his title character as being everybody’s dreams. He doesn’t mean that everyone desires to build a remote opera house but that compulsive dream represents the dreams that everyone has, both great and small. He also said that the only thing that separates him as filmmaker from anyone else is that he could articulate his dream. Our job as humans is to articulate our dreams, “otherwise we would just be cows in a field.”

            His idea of the artist being a person that articulates dreams is a resonant one. This is probably why we are so drawn to many different forms of art. We are moved by the emotional power of music. We don’t need words to feel that power. We can relate and sense the deep connection to life that is expressed there. Visual art does something similar through the filter of its unique expression. Its impact is immediate and direct. With literature, the words of an author help us envision a virtual world that is almost like an alternate universe where we can be the characters about whom we read. We are drawn into that world just as we are with film. We can share the dreams and challenges of those characters and wrestle with their moral dilemmas. We can also project our own dreams into those artistic spaces where we may confront demons in a relatively safe environment as we vicariously work with protagonists in their fictional struggles.

            The vision of the artist is a kind of dream that manifests in the form of the art. This dream can excite us, entertain us, or inspire us in ways that may surprise but usually enliven us. Our own personal dreams do much the same thing except when those may not work as planned, we can experience depression or dramatic life changes. When we are successful, we are fueled to do even more. Artistic dreams, however, are vicarious dreams. We can try them on and remove them time and again, and we can learn from them without having to suffer the consequences of our surrogates. We are most often greatly enriched by the shared dream of the artist, and we should be grateful for their perseverance that brings those dreams to fruition.

Posted on 9/11/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            I started a new painting class today, and since recently there have been a series of articles on FASO about notan, I decided to do a demo for students how this technique can work for simplifying compositions. Novice painters tend to want to use line as a matter of comfort. There is security in an outline; it is so explicit and direct even when it is in the wrong place relative to other parts of the design. I’ve seen students labor at adding shading or color when what really needed to be done was to change a line. No amount of shading is going to make that contour any different when it is in the wrong place. This is the challenge for many students: how to break free of the linear approach to painting.

            One way, of course, is to simplify the entire composition so that lines are not even part of it. There are only large light and dark shapes. These are freely brushed onto the support, but basic parts of the design can still emerge as long as one pays attention to shape and proportion. At this stage, though, it must be kept in mind that detail has no importance. Objects are massed as part of the light area or the dark area only. These polarities are the sole contrasts. There is no single tree or flower or any other solitary item. For some students, this is a difficult concept to grasp. They are mentally locked into the idea of separate objects partly because they are still thinking with words: bottle, flower, table, and so on. Just thinking in terms of shape is too abstract for them to understand, at least initially. Over time it will slowly sink in that all a painter has to work with is a variety of contrasts – light-dark, warm-cool, large-small, smooth-rough, and so on.

It took ten minutes at most to paint the light and dark composition on the 11” x 14” surface. Questions arose about what to do next. Did I have to wait for the paint to dry before proceeding? How would I keep it from smearing?  Why not begin with color? If you’re going to paint over it anyway, why bother with this step? These are reasonable questions from someone who has not grasped the concept of simplification.

            I like to use analogies when explaining certain ideas. A house, for example, is built on a foundation, and a framework is erected on the foundation. Without either, there would be nothing to which we could attach walls or a roof or a floor. The foundation and frame give the house shape and strength, and this is exactly what the composition does for the painting. In a sense, the simpler the composition (as in this case of simple light and dark) the stronger that underlying structure is for the painting.

            I left the demo painting to sit while I talked individually with students about what they were doing. Later I went back to it and dabbed in light and dark values of appropriate colors within the large white and black areas. With just a small amount of color added, most students could see the emerging image. This intrigued them, for most of them had never thought about a painting growing from such an abstract beginning. Of course, not every painter works in this manner, nor should they if they have developed an approach that works well for them. This is part of the beauty and flexibility of the painting process. Still, I want students to have options and not get stuck with the idea that a painting has to look a certain way or that there is only one way of going about making it. I like to show students pictures of paintings made side by side from the same subject by Pissarro and Cezanne. Even though it is the same subject and the points of view are only slightly different, the end results are unique to the individual artist.

            Painters always interpret or translate what they see as they paint. This is where personal expression enters the process. By exploring different approaches, painters can also strengthen their artistic vocabulary. Using this simplification process is one way of doing so.

Posted on 9/10/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            When I was a kid I enjoyed books that contained illustrations to augment stories or other text. I read lots of adventure books, so the illustrations often helped me picture the exotic places that might be in a story. This was an added benefit to the books, and since most of the illustrations were line drawings, it was also a good introduction to visualizing something in graphic form. At the time, however, I had little appreciation of the artistic quality of any of the illustrations. I also remember illustrated Bibles and the illustrations in some textbooks like history and science books. My memory of all those is that they had a strong shared resemblance: soft watercolor pictures with some linear accents and whether depicting Joshua blowing his horn in front of the walls of Jericho, showing cave people huddled around a fire, or picturing frogs swimming in a pond, they all could have been painted by the same artist.

            Many books and periodicals were illustrated with photographs, and since I was particularly captivated by the period of World War II, I got a good grounding in correspondent photography of that era. I still can recall many of those images including ones that became classic. I also remember the drawn images of Howard Brodie and other artists whose names I don’t remember but were published in Stars and Stripes and Yank magazines. These illustrations often conveyed a psychological and emotional side of war that photographs sometimes lacked. It was not until years later that I began to distinguish between illustration and art. That distinction, however, is not always so clear.

            Some fine artists will downplay the work of other artists by saying it is illustrational. What may be suggested is that the work in question depends more on the depicted narrative than the artistic quality of the work. This could certainly be the case with all those textbook illustrations. They were never intended as fine art; their purpose was to illustrate a story. If we compare these to some of Rembrandt’s Biblical drawings, which also are illustrational, how do we say that these are different from other religious illustrations? We could suggest their inventiveness, their heightened sense of design, the masterful use of black and white contrasts, the sense of mood or drama or emotional impact raise them to a higher level of expression. Many illustrations are straightforward representations to simply picture the scene. There is psychological depth and power in Rembrandt drawings that are not evident in much illustrational work. What about drawings found in Da Vinci’s notebooks? Are these illustrational or do they also achieve fine art status? If so, what makes them so? Their initial purpose was to visualize ideas on paper – to picture something, if you will – but not to create images that might be enjoyed for their own sake.

            Is this what differentiates art from illustration, the intention of the artist? Can’t illustrators make art and artists make illustrations? Is it valid to even suggest that illustrational work is too commercial when artists often also desire to sell their work as a commercial product? Is a still life painting or an interior scene any more or less illustrational than a portrait? Is it the interpretive treatment by the artist what raises or lowers a painting as a piece of fine art? Are abstract works automatically considered art instead of illustration or can they be considered illustrations of the artist’s aesthetic ideas? I think that the older I get the more I think in terms of whether a work draws me in and invites me back for a second or third look; that’s the real criteria for appreciation rather than some label that classifies it.

Posted on 9/9/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            On the morning of September 11, 2001, I was on my way to work when I heard the unbelievable report that an airliner had flown into one of the World Trade Center Towers. I remember that in that moment my vision of the world literally shifted, and the view through my car windshield took on a surreal, dreamlike appearance. It was as though I were moving through water instead of air. I called my wife to see whether she had heard any other news, but she had not until she turned on the television. As we all know, for days thereafter news reports were constant. I continued on to work where I found the entire school staff surrounding the small television set that was in the library. There we all witnessed the first plane and later the second plane striking the towers again and again. It felt very much like the movie that is so well done that even though you know what will happen, you sit spellbound in the possibility that this time someone will avert the disaster.

            Much speculation ensued in the aftermath of that morning. The course of the nation and the lives of millions of people were irrevocably changed. Some tried to imagine the horrors that those in the towers must have faced especially those who chose to jump rather than be burned alive. So what does this have to do with art, you might ask? Quite a lot actually. Several very powerful artworks came from the ashes of that tragedy. One of the first was the documentary by the Naudet brothers who happened to be in New York on that day filming the activities of a company of firefighters in Lower Manhattan. The brothers caught both aircraft impacting the towers as well as the collapse of the North Tower as seen from inside the South Tower. Their documentary 9/11 was released in 2002 and was shown on public television.

            Another emotionally wrenching film is Paul Greengrass’s 2006 United 93, a fictionalized account of the heroic activity of passengers aboard the doomed flight that crashed into a Pennsylvania field. The film is a powerfully told narrative of the events that occurred far from New York that same fateful day. Like any effective piece of art, the film puts viewers right into that space and time, and we no doubt find ourselves rooting for those rebellious passengers hoping that they will succeed even though we know the inevitable outcome. It is probably the best fictional work to deal with those events. Thought provoking and emotionally draining, it is not an easy film to watch.

            We often use the phrases aesthetic distance and suspension of disbelief in relation to certain forms of art but particularly theater and film. Over theater, film has a significant edge since it can present images far more realistically with much greater visual impact. Still, we know that we are not in the reality of whatever situations are playing out on the screen. We have distance. We are on the outside looking in no matter how good we might be at projecting ourselves into the story. With stories that we have lived with or lived through, the experience may be more affecting as when former soldiers have flashbacks while viewing combat films.

            Art has power on its own to create amazing experiences for an audience. It is all the more powerful when it weds an intense narrative like United 93 or Zero Dark Thirty to the tools of the filmmaker. Whether we call this entertainment or not seems irrelevant even though both of these examples come out of the entertainment industry. These are fictionalized stories just as The Last King of Scotland or Raid on Entebbe, two other films that dealt with heavy, real-life drama in very effective ways. It is said that truth is stranger than fiction, but fiction can also reveal truth in ways that enable us to deal with either or both.

Posted on 9/8/2013 6:42:52 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Artists, philosophers, and aestheticians have been discussing and writing about art for several hundred years. Sometimes the rhetoric is quite heated as there are disagreements about many aspects of art: inspiration, purpose, importance, value, and impact. Some of the rhetoric is quite verbose and dense and may leave many readers scratching their heads as to meaning. I don’t doubt, however, that every artist has strong personal views about art, what it is or can be, why it is done, and its place in society. Some language used by artists also becomes inflated and flowery, almost hyperbolic, perhaps to underline the importance that the artist gives to art in his or her life. All of that is okay unless one happens to be the reader or listener to the poetically inclined author. Art certainly is broad enough a subject to include almost any interpretation that may be inflicted upon it.

            When I think about art, I do recognize first and foremost that I give it great importance in my life and in the life of the planet. It has a history nearly as long as the history of human beings. How and why people first made art is unknown and possibly unknowable. Again, there are various theories some of which are quite complex. Those may be interesting and sometimes I enjoy exploring them, but for me art is always a construct. It has no inherent value just as a tree or flower or most anything else has no inherent value. We, as humans, give value to pretty much everything we experience. Gold is only valuable because a huge number of people agree that it is so. The same can be said of diamonds or any monetary currency – all valuable by agreement. Historically, we can see the value of art go up or down depending on its favorability at any given time. Some may argue this point and say that all art has value just because it’s art – it is someone’s personal expression, but that’s just another opinion thrown into the mix.

            To me, though, art is an idea or emotional feeling that is given concrete form by someone because it feels important to that person to do so. The resultant art may or may not be sold in the marketplace. If it is, then it also has become a commodity, which has been assigned some value that two or more parties agree upon. Once that happens the art in question is either diminished or enhanced in value depending whether the price value is considered acceptable. However, art is also appreciated for other qualities that it may appear to possess: beauty, quality, skill of the maker, originality, or appeal. If we were to place a masterful Golden Age Dutch painting next to a German Expressionist painting, what would be the likely response to questions of beauty or quality or skill? Some people will choose one painting over the other for various reasons, and that is as it should be, for this is part of the way that we relates to art on a very personal level.

            There is nothing particularly magical about art although some will say that there is. There is mystery behind the inspiration, the process, and the appreciation of the completed work. Whatever an artist has put into a work may not be the same as what a viewer gets out of it. Sometimes the artist may not be fully aware of all that the work may hold; others may see more than was consciously intended. This is also part of the mystery, but that may have more to do with human perception than with art unless we think of art as having been developed to give expression and form to that which often seems beyond expressibility. I like to think this is the case. Our ability to create and to respond to symbols and metaphors may have developed as a means to express the ineffable. The way that we do this is mostly through art.

Posted on 9/7/2013 6:46:36 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Learning a skill takes time, a lot of practice, patience, and the determination to stick with the process. Giving up or giving in will sabotage all effort to date regardless of intention. The process can’t be hurried either although some people may pick up skills more easily than others especially when a skill is related to something with which that person already has familiarity. More frequent practice done diligently may also increase the rate of skill development, but some skills still need time to simmer and assimilate into muscle memory.

            Athletes understand this process well and spend appropriate amounts of time practicing drills, exercising to build strength, flexibility, and agility, and maintain a healthy diet to properly fuel the body. In professional sports as well as in high level amateur sports, experienced coaches and trainers are consulted in order to maximize results while avoiding injury.

            Patience is a quality that can nurture the learning process, but many people find themselves short of patience when the process seems to take much longer than expected. A painting student, for example, may regularly attend classes once or twice a week but feel frustrated when not progressing as quickly as desired. Patience is necessary here. If the student can paint more frequently, every day perhaps, the progression would be faster, but this is up to the student. Therefore, a realistic expectation based on the time commitment will be important to understand. This should be communicated by the instructor. Even so, there is no magic time frame, no specific number of hours in which a new skill can be perfected. Desire and focus also figure into the process.

            An old Zen saying is that you can’t push the river. It flows at its own pace. Impatience will impede progress just as stones in the river will divert the flow of water. Can someone learn patience though? An art professor from many years ago once told me that painting teaches two things: patience and humility. He believed that patience can be taught, and it is that day to day practice which does just that. After quite a few years, I tend to agree with him, but I also know that patience does not preclude experiencing frustration when the process does not go well. That is where perseverance comes in, and we keep pressing forward until progress is made.

Posted on 9/6/2013 5:43:22 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Yesterday I was thinking about art history and specific dates that have significance, ones that might be called flashbulb moments. Today in my Speech Communication class we discussed effective teamwork, and one of the effects from teams working synergistically is the creation of broader perspectives. I suggested that many students have complained in the past about several subjects that are largely disliked. Mention math or English or History and students often screw up their faces and begin to lodge complaints. I then wrote a list of dates on the board since names, dates, or places are the challenge of many history courses.

July 4, 1776                             November 19, 1863   

December 7, 1941                  August 28, 1963

November 22, 1963                September 11, 2001

            I then said that history is about people and the things that happen to them. I suggested that some of the students had direct experience with some of the dates, but even if they didn’t, they had friends or family members who did. Those dates would have been important to them, but in actuality each of those dates has ongoing impacts in the lives of every one of us. We simply need to recognize the connection.

            Most people usually recognize the date given as the birth of our country. That is a significant date for which we should express gratitude every day. There are many people who strongly desire to live in a country like ours. No one recognized the date that Gettysburg battlefield was memorialized and Abraham Lincoln made his famous speech about “government of the people, by the people, and for the people” not perishing from the earth. Several students guessed the 1941 date as related to World War II but didn’t recognize it as the date Pearl Harbor was bombed by the Japanese, and America entered the war. Almost one hundred years after Lincoln’s address, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. stood on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial and made his “I Have a Dream” speech. We just celebrated the 50th anniversary of that momentous occasion and its effects on the Civil Rights Movement. One student did recognize the November 1963 date as the day JFK was assassinated. The shock of that is still felt by many who either lived through it or knew those who did. Everyone, of course, recognized 9/11, and everyone remembered exactly what they had been doing and thinking that day when they heard about the World Trade Towers.

            The point here is that dates and times are important to us, and we often have unseen connections to people and events that impact us in significant ways. History is the story of these events, these people, and these connections. For many centuries art has created signposts for events, sometimes chronicling them, sometimes memorializing them, and sometimes critiquing them. Quite a few pieces of art have created their own historical statement as watershed moments for new ways of thinking and new ways of doing something creative. Their impact has lasted many generations and will continue into the foreseeable future. They have become links in a long historical chain that connects present to past and suggests possibility for the future. When we ignore such links, we discount a huge part of who we are as part of a larger continuum. Many flashbulb moments illumine the whole of human society.  

             

Posted on 9/5/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            When we look at art history, there are many significant works that are flashbulbs for specific time periods. Other pieces or events revolve around those pieces because they were so unique or groundbreaking in their time. Quite a few of those pieces do not have specific dates; there are generalities that locate them in time. The cave paintings from Lascaux or Altamira, for example, are only generally placed chronologically. The same is true for massive structures like the Great Pyramid or the Sphinx. They were constructed over many decades during the reign of specific pharaohs, Khufu and Khafre respectively, approximately 2500 BCE. Even by the time of Classical Greece, dates for specific artworks are approximate. With many of these examples, people would have seen the work slowly progressing year after year, and the completion may not have been specifically noticed.

            By the time we get to the Italian Renaissance, dates seem to be more important and records are more precisely kept. Whether this indicates a philosophical shift in thinking, a more acute concern regarding mortality, or obsessiveness with detail is debatable. Certainly as measurement of time becomes more precise, so does the observance of specific dates for achievements. Art becomes a precise chronological time marker. What painting student doesn’t know the Salon of 1863, often considered the birth of the avant-garde? Or, who hasn’t heard of the 1905 Salon D’Automne when the wild beasts reared their heads?

            The public impact of some of these works, though significant within certain circles of the time, has certainly grown historically since. The same might be said of other important historical dates that have nothing to do with art like November 19, 1863; December 7, 1941; June 6, 1944; November 22, 1963; or September 11, 2001. These are all iconic American dates although several have important international reverberations as well. Cultural flashbulb memories like these have a power that implants them deep within our psyches, but some dates that we did not directly experience can also have important effects in our lives, which is the point of my remarks here.

            Those events that we do experience directly form quick associations with other circumstances, and we recall not only the major event itself but also those things that we were doing or thinking when the major event occurred. I was not at Gettysburg or Pearl Harbor or Normandy, but I have seen how the events connected with them have affected my parents and their generation as well as my own. One doesn’t have to look too closely to see ripples from America’s decisions to drop atomic bombs on Japan still reverberating nearly seventy years later. It is only one of several reasons why some countries still do not trust the United States. These kinds of significant events whether related to war or assassinations or aggressions should be remembered just as the positive contributions from inventions, artistic expressions, and cultural contributions should also be remembered.

            We are all something of a jumble of good and not so good. We do great things, and we make mistakes. We create remarkable beauty and accomplish amazing achievements. We also disregard others, make horrific blunders, and commit unforgivable atrocities. This is the history of the human race. Art has captured elements of that time and again century after century and hopefully will continue to do so.

Posted on 9/4/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Several times a month I go to an acupuncturist, something I’ve done for about four years now. I first met him when he was a senior student at the American College of Acupuncture here in Houston, a well-known and highly respected school in this country. Almost all the teachers on staff are Chinese acupuncturists many of them with long years of practice. My family doctor serves on the college’s board. I was seen by my friend throughout his senior year, and after he graduated, became licensed, and established his own practice, I followed him there. Unlike many of the students from the college, he also is Chinese.

            Periodically, he gives me small gifts that are art related since he knows that I am an artist. At the beginning of this year he gave me a beautiful calendar illustrated with the work of a famous Chinese painter. I can read the numbers but nothing else, the rest being in Chinese. However, the ink paintings of contemporary China are extraordinarily beautiful. Today he gave me two books about contemporary Chinese painting, one focused on a single artist and the other a survey of different painters and several photographers. The text of both is in Chinese, but this does not affect the images.

             Several interesting thoughts come to mind as I leaf through the books. Most obvious is the universality of art. Whether paintings of landscapes, village scenes, people going about daily tasks, or still life paintings, the common humanity is apparent. Buildings, people, and landscape are recognizably oriental, but the styles of most of the paintings are not traditional although some reflect traditional roots. Many are, in fact, quite modern looking, and some early twentieth century western influence is visible. The earliest dated work in the survey volume is 1935, and the most recent is 1993. Works range from watercolor to oil and also include about a dozen photographs. Some of the landscapes are expressive with thick swaths of paint laid on with a palette knife. Others are more impressionistic done in bright, broken strokes of color.

            However European some of these references may be, there is still an Eastern sense of nature that comes from several thousand years of contemplation of the natural world and man’s place in it. The poetry that comes through the fine distillation of form that much brush and ink painting has where a few delicate strokes of ink capture that essential life force in a blade of bamboo or wing of a butterfly can be felt in the majority of these images. The few exceptions are more dramatic statements that portray a raw energy that is less lyrical and quiet.

            Regardless of culture, although artists may be profoundly influenced by it, artists do create a visionary response to the world in which they live. Culture informs certain ways of seeing and describing, but artists more often than not transcend that stricture to present a broader picture that incorporates culture into the artistic vision. Thus, the arts tend to redefine culture even in the process of creating it. The visions that are created help us to see more deeply into life and to better understand the processes of which we are a part.

Posted on 9/3/2013
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            Teaching is challenging from any perspective, for it requires not only knowledge of one’s subject and demonstrated skills with particular subjects, but also patience, understanding, and the ability to listen. It isn’t only about giving information or showing someone how to do something. Different students require different approaches, and a good teacher has to be flexible enough to accommodate the needs of all students. In academic classes I always have prepared lesson plans usually with an entire course mapped out ahead of time. There are course objectives in place to meet the basic requirements of accrediting agencies, but even so there can be flexibility within that rather strict framework to adjust to the needs of a class and to work with feedback that comes from students. Art classes are different, especially painting classes, for now students are learning to develop personal skills and to express that inner creative urge rather than meet some academic requirement. In some ways these classes are more fun, but over time most teachers learn how to make learning a fun process.

            Sometimes, though, and I’m sure that other teachers will have variations on this idea, one comes across a student or students that think they know more than they actually do. Or, they may have a lot of learned information, but they don’t yet know how to use it. Or, their understanding is flawless, and everyone else is far behind them, or so they think. In short, this kind of student has a real ego problem. They actually resist learning even though they go through the motions because they are convinced that they have achieved a level of expertise that excels over their peers. In the arts, unfortunately, their issues are obvious to everyone but themselves, and it is most obvious in their work.

            When I was in graduate school, I saw quite a few students like this disappear after a few months into the program, certainly after the first faculty review. Those students were dealt with harshly and weeded out because I now think the faculty knew they would sabotage the learning opportunities of other students. Almost all artists meet with rejection even when they have achieved a certain level of ability. It’s the nature of the game. These students were essentially given the choice to listen or leave. The faculty partly saw their job as toughening students to deal with future rejection in the larger art world. In a sense, their harsh criticism was a kindness.

            This is generally not my way, especially with art, for I know from my own experience how difficult the artistic path can be. I want to encourage rather than discourage even if the discouragement is intended as a kind of encouragement over the long term – negative reinforcement, if you will. The learning process is challenging enough without it becoming a battle of egos. Others may say, well, there are times when you just have to tell the truth. Maybe that person should be doing something else. The again, that stubborn soul has yet to experience the epiphany that will change his or her perspective that will allow the unleashing of all that creative potential. Our learning processes can be so radically different for each of us!

            As a teacher, you can tell, you can show, you can cajole, you can trick, you can entertain, and you can do anything you can think of to get a point across, but you can’t make anyone do anything. That has to come from within. They will get it or they won’t, and if they don’t, then hopefully they will get it at some later time. That’s the real gift, when one of those students returns at a later time and says, “You know when you were trying to get me to… Well, I finally figured it out.”

Posted on 9/2/2013 1:33:48 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            When I was about ten or eleven years old, that summer a great fire broke out in the woods north of where we lived. Our neighborhood was separated from the woods by a railroad line that served as a natural firebreak. The woods sometimes came right up to the tracks, but in several places there were grassy meadows between the tracks and the woods, which consisted mostly of pine trees interspersed with deciduous oak, maple and various other trees. Those woods ran for miles east and west and further north from the neighborhood. They served as playgrounds for neighborhood kids and bird hunters. We often camped there and explored every inch over the course of a summer.

            The fire coincided with domestic difficulties, and a few years ago I wrote a short story based on that time period using the great fire as a central metaphor. Coincidentally, today is the day on which the great fire that devastated London broke out in 1666. At that time most of the buildings were made of wood, which meant that the fire spread very rapidly. Even though much of the city was destroyed, there were several beneficial results as well. One result is that large numbers of rats and their fleas were eliminated, and that brought an end to the plague that had run rampant for several years. A second result is that many of the buildings known today were built in replacement of those destroyed. Quite a few of these were designed by Sir Christopher Wren, arguably one of the greatest architects England has produced.

            It is interesting that Wren was not noted for architecture at that time. He was a scientist, a true Renaissance man better known as an astronomer, inventor, lecturer, an Oxford don, and one of the founders of the Royal Society. His scientific work was admired by Sir Isaac Newton and Blaise Pascal among others. As a surveyor, he became instrumental in the rebuilding of London, and he was actively involved in the design and building of at least fifty churches including what is considered his masterpiece, St. Paul’s Cathedral.  He had studied the designs of buildings in France and Italy, in particular the architectural drawings of Bernini (most popularly known for The Ecstasy of Saint Theresa).

            Obviously Christopher Wren was a man of many talents and great intellect, but his life also reflects the idea of being in the right place at the right time – and being prepared. His wide ranging interests not only gave him skills in many areas but they also brought him into contact with the leading minds of his time. In modern terms we could say that he was a networker extraordinaire. He learned from others as readily as he shared his own knowledge with them. His knowledge of mathematics and interest in architecture enabled him to become one of the greatest architectural designers of his age by making the most of the opportunity presented him by what could have been considered a great tragedy.

            Life is full of unexpected twists and turns, but most of the great teachers say that we are never given more than we can handle. When we approach challenges with the proper mindset, we can often come through stronger and more confident in our ability to succeed. Wren exemplified this throughout his long career. He lived to the age of 91, which is especially remarkable for the time in which he lived. Like many great achievers he also remained active and engaged until the end. There is much to learn from historical figures besides admiration for their accomplishments.

Posted on 9/1/2013 4:58:25 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this


            A major amount of art is composed as beautiful images that stand alone to be contemplated as creative statements or to decorate a variety of furnishings and utensils. The purpose of this art is to uplift and to show the positive side of human creativity that reflects love for life, for each other, and for the planet that sustains us. Also, there is a substantial amount of art that depicts a darker, pessimistic, and depressing side of humanity that is connected with fear, anger, conflict, and self-destructive tendencies. Some art may be predominantly positive but contain a hint of the negative or fatalistic reference. Other art may be mainly negative yet contain some sense of hope for a more positive outcome. As individuals we may be attracted to one form over the other, but even when we prefer one, we cannot altogether ignore the other. This would be foolish and unrealistic.

            More than a hundred years ago, Charles Dickens began one of his most famous novels with the lines, "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair, we had everything before us, we had nothing before us, we were all going direct to Heaven, we were all going direct the other way – in short, the period was so far like the present period, that some of its noisiest authorities insisted on its being received, for good or for evil, in the superlative degree of comparison only" (Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities).

            Those words are most appropriate to the world today. Scientific and technological advances have saved more lives and brought more people together than at any other time in history. Life expectancy far exceeds that of fifty years ago. That is, in certain areas of the world this is true. However, there are many places where life expectancy is short because lack of food and water and presence of disease create brutal living conditions. The gap between the haves and the have-nots continues to grow, and this is likely setting the stage for future conflicts between classes of people.

            The world of nature has also felt the brunt of continued growth, increase in human population, and subsequent environmental effects from our dependence on fossil fuels. Regardless of what climate change deniers may say, it cannot be argued that world population has not more than doubled since the publication of Paul Ehrlich’s The Population Bomb in the late sixties. It is projected that there will be over nine billion people on earth by the year 2050. That’s less than forty years from now, the equivalent of someone’s working career. We seem to continue to ignore the problem. It is potential suicide for a politician to take a strong stance on any environmental issue or even one that calls for sacrifice for the benefit of future generations.

            A friend recently shared the link to a YouTube video by a photographer who has been documenting some of the effects of our indifference. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MN8JYhByVYg

The video was filmed on Midway Island, as remote a location as any on the planet, and yet… well, take a look. There is beauty and there is horror. There is a face looking back from this dark mirror, and that face is one we all know well.  Art is a mirror more often than not, but it doesn’t always reflect what we expect to see.