Blog
Posted on 3/31/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Art history courses give little more than an overview of what has taken place in the history of art. Typically, within any given time period, which starts out early on considering thousands of years, then is concentrated within centuries down to a single century, and ultimately to a movement that spans less than a generation, we might see a dozen or more works that represent any of those periods. A single artist, however, could easily create hundreds of works within his or her lifetime, and of those a small number could be considered masterpieces or, if that term is too grandiose, then we say mature works. It is little wonder that many of us carry around a skewed version of what has been done in art over the centuries.
Compare the visual artist to the literary artist, particularly a novelist, who might pen anywhere from one to a dozen or more books within that same working period of time. A single work could make the reputation of a writer – think of writers as disparate as Melville with Moby Dick and Salinger with A Catcher in the Rye. Melville is often credited with having written the great American novel, and yet most people would be hard pressed to name another work by his hand. Harper Lee wrote one major work in To Kill a Mockingbird and then retired from the literary scene that she never actually fit into to begin with. The jury is still out on the supposed second novel that she may never have intended to see published.
There are few painters that are known for a single work. We might think of Leonardo and the Mona Lisa, or Michelangelo and the Sistine Chapel ceiling, but the former is also widely known for his inventive work and some other paintings (especially by those who know something of the Renaissance) and the latter is known as much for his sculpture as for his painting (David, of course). Without too much difficulty, we could find other examples of paintings by these and other masters. Even when working with the big names of art, it is in the details that the real history is told. Every artist had a life and worked every day, perhaps without even thinking so much about how he might be remembered (although also quite aware of those artists that preceded and transferred their influence).
Still, we can’t see only one Cubist painting and comprehend all the assumptions underlying the whys and wherefores of these paintings. Museums will often focus on a time period or on select works by a single artist in order to show more depth to the work and contribute to the understanding of the particular artist’s oeuvre or body of work. Any single painting may be an important component of that work, and that painting may be fully appreciated as a singular work of art. Even so, it may be perceived differently when placed in the context of other works done within the same year or within a brief span of years on either side of that one piece. It is my contention that painting, more so than literature, is created within a context and that pieces relate to other pieces as parts of a larger statement about art (for that artist).
There could be a lengthy discussion here about style, the painter’s handwriting, the painter’s palette, the choice of subjects, and the many other factors that contribute to what makes one painter different from another. Soon the critique of the work would look like any critique of any other maker of art in any medium since we’d be considering many of the same types of influences that artists tend to experience: the work of predecessors, the time within which they work, social and cultural issues, specific artistic concerns, and the overall pattern of art history. We’d also have to ask the question of the artist, is it the individual work that matters most or is it that work in context of the entire body of work that matters? Is it what takes place in the moment of creation or in that moment related to all other creative moments? Can the artist truthfully answer that question him or herself? Personally, I’m not so sure.
Posted on 3/30/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Reading a novel is quite different from reading a painting. The former develops sequentially if not always chronologically. One chapter follows another as the narrative unfolds, and though some novelists may experiment with time, use flashbacks or flash-forwards, the narrative is a series of related events. We follow the action and the development of characters as they deal with their choices and consequences. The reader, then, can read small or large sections at a time and vary that amount according to choice, and sometimes a reader might re-read parts before moving ahead in the narrative.
A viewer of a painting, on the other hand, will most likely begin with an overall view of the whole before narrowing focus to smaller parts. The parts only make sense in relation to the whole. It would be rare for a viewer to look only at one part and then another and then another until mentally piecing them all together to gain understanding of the whole. A painting is a kind of Gestalt image where the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. Any of the parts may be scrutinized, but it is only in relation to the whole that those parts have value.
We can move through a narrative much as we move through our day to day lives, which is lived part by part even though we may consciously consider it as a whole thing within every moment. I can be in the moment, but I also experience the moment in relation to what has come before and project through expectations what may come after. As I experience a painting over time, on the other hand, I may develop a kind of narrative of that painting (of the experience of that painting) and stitch together ideas from previous viewings to what I am seeing in the moment. Also, as I learn more about the painting from my observations, I begin to understand it and its parts differently from that initial experience of the whole. I see it as more complex and multi-faceted.
Similarly with literature, we uncover its complexity of design as we experience the narrative and hints of the underlying craft of the writer in so much as that can be discerned. The story may deepen in meaning as we learn more about characters, their motivations, and see in the writer’s use of language, description, and imagery how this particular art work develops and ultimately contains all that it holds in its artistic possibility.
All forms of art have possibility of multiple meanings and multiple perspectives from which they may be seen or discovered. This is part of what makes the expression the thing that we call art. It is creative possibility available for discovery. That is its mystery and its magic.
Posted on 3/29/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Today’s The Painter’s Keys is titled “A Wonderful Line,” a re-boot of a 2004 post that focuses on the graphic art of Egon Schiele, the Austrian painter associated with Art Nouveau (Jugendstil) who died in 1918. He was only twenty-eight years old when he succumbed to the flu close to the end of World War I (http://painterskeys.com/a-wonderful-line/). I remember first seeing reproductions of Schiele’s drawings in a bookstore in Chapel Hill, N.C. back in 1965. I was stunned by the raw lyricism of his erratic line that pulsated with a kind of energy I did not know could be conveyed in graphic form. A few years later I saw original works in Washington and sometime later in New York. They were even more powerful as original relics from the hand of the artist as though a personal letter had been delivered into one’s private care.
Drawing is so simple and direct in its traveling distance from the mind of the artist to his/her audience. It is unfiltered compared to painting or other forms of visual art. Drawing also gives an intimate look into both the life and mind of the artist. In Schiele’s case, his drawings show an active and somewhat tortured soul who obviously felt the intensity of the time in which he lived. There is often great irony in these intimate works being displayed so publicly in museums and galleries or today on the internet. The sometimes decadent circumstance of a life lived from choice on the outside of social decorum or one caught up in the turmoil of war or poverty may appear incongruent with pristine walls and the clean, well-lighted space of a public hall devoted to the highest expression of the beautiful. Many great names have given us glimpses of things far from our own personal experience: Goya, Manet, Degas, Lautrec, Kollwitz, Schiele, Grosz, Bellmer, Picasso… – it is a lengthy list and these are but a few examples. Ironically, too, there often is great beauty in how these unconventional and sometimes grotesque images are presented to us.
In a great many ways, art is the great melting pot, it is the destroyer of separation and discrimination, it is the clear voice of reason or the rant of the irrational, and it is the harbinger of unfettered emotion not necessarily recollected in tranquility. The Madonna and the whore hang alongside the idol and the hanged man in those public halls. Drawings in the private leaves of sketchbooks can be far more incongruous and inclusive.
Posted on 3/28/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I enjoy action and crime dramas: filmed, televised, and written. I’ll amend that by saying that I enjoy dramas that are thoughtful, witty, intriguing, and not simply about blowing things up or expressing savagery. In other words, those dramas do what art and literary works have done since the earliest Greek tragedies and epic poems. They present a conflict between good and evil, choice and fate, and sometimes blur the line so that telling one from the other is not so clear. In essence, art presents the conflicts that we experience in life in scenarios that involve us emotionally and allow us to consider choices without us having to face permanent consequences. We can revisit narratives at will, consider characters and their actions at leisure, and philosophize about how these things might affect us if we were in the same situations. We can also experience the power of image or language or symbolic expression. Ultimately we learn about the world, exercise our powers of perception and imagination, and practice understanding through the eyes of more than one person.
The greatest art and literature has always challenged its audience emotionally, intellectually, and spiritually if not also morally. There are themes and dramatic situations that transcend cultural limits and national boundaries. A story may be flavored by a particular locale, but what is in the human heart rings true regardless of place of origin. Nobel laureates include authors from all over the world. A story set in ancient Greece can be just as moving as one set in the American West or Stalinist Russia. A wartime painting by Goya can be just as arresting as one by Picasso, both Spaniards, but one a court painter and the other one who lived among the lower middle class in France.
Not all art will deal with such moral questions, nor will it address life or death situations. Some artists will look to the beauty of nature in order to celebrate that in painted form. Others will create images that previously inhabited the mind of the artist and no one else. The viewer is provided with intimate views of another’s interior world. Any of these works may also reach far beyond the singular audience and provide a meeting point for the collective mind to share commonality of purpose and vision. In short, art is the meeting place for human experience.
Posted on 3/27/2016 5:05:35 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

The seeds of change are always among us, for change is the one ironic constant that we can count on. Many resist the idea of change, and the reasons behind that are abundant. Some may fear change because it is a reminder that there are forces in life beyond our control. This fact, however, is abundantly clear – just look out the window on any given day and see whatever weather condition Mother Nature has provided. We cannot order this like steak from a menu. The greatest fear of change, however, may be that change from life to death.
It is not surprising, then, that many cultures address this final transition though their art. Mythological and religious stories are filled with references to this ultimate change and offer some attempt at guidance by personifying death, building narratives about heroic champions struggling with darkness, or suggesting some triumphant release into existence far greater than what we know in our mortal form. Today is Easter, one of the most important days for Christians since it is the day that Christ overcame mortality by rising from the dead. Christians even speak of being reborn (a kind of resurrection) into a new life, for now “death where is thy sting?”
Spiritual transition, spiritual change, is as old as civilization. And there is evidence of this concept from pre-history. Many are familiar with Ancient Egyptian practices, at least among the ruling class, of burying goods, animals, and sometimes other people along with the eminent deceased to both ease the transition from one life to the next and to serve in the afterlife. More than memorializing the departed, the ritual and offerings were practical actions on the part of those laying the departed to rest. In a sense, there was recognition of and embracing of the change in ritualized fashion. Graves of anonymous individuals thousands of years prior to Mesopotamian and Egyptian cultures suggest that they too believed something about transitioning to another life given the inclusion of artifacts that might prove useful in the unforeseen future.
A huge amount of art has been created to acknowledge, to illuminate, to celebrate, and to critique change as it is experienced in human life, in the world of nature, and at all levels of existence. Change can be resisted and feared, sought and embraced, or ritualized and celebrated. Whether observing the seasons, particular weather patterns, natural growth cycles, life spans, or the course of a single day, artists are keenly aware of all aspects of change and how these affect our lives. Artists are also very much aware of the importance of change in the creation of any single art piece. In many ways, art is as much about change, perhaps more so about change, as/than about anything else.
Posted on 3/26/2016 7:31:04 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

In daily life and activity, we make decisions and take actions to accomplish and move forward. Many things are memorable and we carry their memories with us. Inevitably, we also make mistakes and later work to undo or amend and sometimes forget our errors. Over time we remember and we forget. Our memories may be altered by passage of time, the accumulation of new experience and knowledge, or relief from poor choices and the sting of guilt when our actions may have caused suffering or injury to others. However we may live our lives, our imperfections help us to learn and grow or stand as obstacles that impede progress. Everyone is different with regard to outcome.
Artistic expression is one way, among other things, to ameliorate the challenges of our lives. It can teach lessons, create diversion and entertainment, provide space for contemplation, or elevate our understanding and perception of the world. Artists often mirror aspects of our lives through their art, and the art making process itself stand as a metaphor for the creative change in the process of life.
My exploration of idea and experience through art has for many years been a conscious effort to express thoughts and feelings about existence, awareness, and perception. A painting or drawing can be a representation of something observed, or of something felt, and exist as a collection of colored shapes and marks to be read as a viewer may choose. The works also, for me, reflect our daily experience of doing, experiencing, perceiving, and remembering pieces and parts of those experiences. Sometimes experiences blend together, or parts of one experience carries into another, or memories of several coalesce into something new and different worth contemplating on its own as a separate entity.
A painting always begins in one place within a frame or visual space and then accumulates more color, shape, or line so that every new part affects the experience of what is already there including the whole space. The new may partially or completely obliterate the old. Something may be added or taken away. The whole shifts and changes in its process of becoming. This to my mind is exactly like the shifts and changes that occur in life.
I am particularly aware of this in recent drawings. I use colored pencil, graphite, and charcoal pencils to create words and shapes. These are expressed gesturally, geometrically, and repetitively to create rhythm and structure. I sometimes use templates to create precise shapes or lines, including shapes over words or words over shapes. Also, I frequently work back into an area with erasers to alter or to remove lines or shapes and to create new shapes by deletion. A drawing develops from many layers of line and shape by adding to and taking away. Again, for me this process is a perfect metaphor for both everyday experience and for our experience over time.
Posted on 3/25/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Quite a lot of twentieth century American painting has an industrial feel to it. The scale of the works was intended to surround the viewer or at least fill his or her visual field with color and painted shape. It wasn’t that Pop artists like James Rosenquist happened to be trained as a billboard painter and therefore created massive works that could only be appreciated from a distance. Painters who did abstract work also painted gigantic paintings that were painted from inside out, so to speak – the paintings were created on the floor with the artist walking on the canvas to make an image that eventually would be stretched and hung on a wall. These were mural sized pieces that had little to do with traditional easel painting.
This is not to say that large scale works were new. Large scale advertising was a modern invention, but it likely grew out of mural painting in some way. During the Renaissance, very large works were painted for patrons to cover the bare walls of castles and palaces just as tapestries were used for the same purpose. These paintings, however, had complex compositions with lots of figures engaged with religious or Classical mythological narrative themes. Some of the early modern abstractionists kept the connection to myth and spirituality expressed in their titles, but some American painting veered increasingly toward reductive image and content, especially among the so-called color field painters. Jackson Pollock’s early abstract experiments were often blends of surrealist images and mythical figures, but he gradually eliminated literary content as the images became dense strings and spatters of paint, and the paintings were distinguished by numbers rather than names.
As an action painter, though, Pollock was directly involved with the making of his works. Many other painters used numerous assistants to help create paintings that would have been very challenging for one person to create completely by himself. This aspect of modern painting also has roots in the Renaissance and the artist workshops where experienced assistants painted backgrounds or specific parts of a picture. The master would then add significant figures after the rest had been prepared. However, there is no mention that Michelangelo had painting assistants for the Sistine Chapel. It is understandable that given many commissions, a painter might need to rely on assistants to help maintain a hectic schedule and complete works. The same could be said for the modern counterparts, but with the latter, perhaps because of the dramatic change in imagery and the frequent use of industrial materials to create them, the painting process took on a feel of manufacture rather than artistic expression and production.
Ironically, during this time of experimentation and sometimes identification with building and industry by one group of so-called mainstream artists, there also was the development of the craft movement where artists and artisans turned away from the idea of manufacturing to direct hands-on involvement in the creative process. Ceramists, printmakers, papermakers focused increasingly on artistry and the making of beautiful objects (many potters became sculptors) while painters began to revitalize plein air painting and easel painting in the studio. We can still find segments of the artistic community where for a painting to be considered serious, it has to be mural-sized scale.
I don’t intend for any of this to be definitive, for with the plethora of styles and approaches taken by artists today that may well be impossible. These are simply thoughts based on observations of lots of work over a period of years. Personally, I love the great variety of art these days.
Posted on 3/24/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Young writers are often advised to “write what you know” when they express a desire to make a significant literary impact. Many young artists harbor that yearning to create the next breakthrough statement – literary, visual, or otherwise. When I was in English graduate school in the late sixties, there was focus on early twentieth century American writers who wanted to write the great American novel – writers like Hemingway, Fitzgerald, Wolfe, or Faulkner among others. Some suggested that Melville had already written the great novel in Moby Dick, but great as that novel is and utterly American in tone, it certainly can be argued that life at sea is a remote metaphor for life in America. That novel couldn’t express the cultural mix of living on the North American continent.
Young artists may be filled with energy and desire, but they often lack life experience no matter how precocious their creative energies may be. The impetuousness of youth seldom produces the greatest art. At some point, however, sooner for some than others, the young artist will mature and gain insight into what critics refer to as the human condition, that area where the greatest art makes the strongest impact. It may be in the guise of whalers in doomed pursuit of the elusive prize, sad harlequins and circus characters who appear to carry the weight of existence in bluish tones, or broken strokes of vibrant color that appear to make a landscape shimmer with glowing light. The symbolic and metaphorical repurposing of ordinary experience whether action oriented, sweeping masculine gestures or philosophical starts and stops within the jumbled thoughts of a single consciousness, the well-trained, perceptive, and inspired artist will make the most of his or her insight and captivate the imagination of his /her potential audience. The artist has to be ready and only the individual artist will know how to prepare him or herself for that appointed task.
Write what you know? Paint what you know? The knowing, it seems to me, is about knowing oneself, then getting out of the way to become the instrument of expression that will inevitably pour forth. There is no second-guessing this process no matter how many opinions there may be about what should or should not happen to bring it about. History has shown us so many manifestations of artistic genius in a dizzying array of media, styles, visual and verbal language, and range of expression that by now we should know that nature, human nature, will find a way to express itself.
Posted on 3/23/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

These days I think about painting as a process of discovery. I suppose actually that I’ve always thought about painting in that way. When I did a lot of landscape painting, the discovery had to do with what I might come to understand about a particular setting or location or the relationship of objects found in nature within their specific spatial area. This had a lot to do with studying light and form and color and how these made something appear a certain way to the eye. Paint would be used to then restate that set of observed relationships in an interesting design within the framework of the paper or canvas. In short, I would be observing and manipulating all the things that artists have been observing and manipulating for centuries in the process of making art, not just slavishly duplicating an image.
This process led me at different times to explore color, shape, and form, and suggested light produced by paint without specific reference to something observed. This is a fancy way of saying abstract painting, but I’ve never really liked the term abstract or abstraction – it’s too ambiguous. I prefer to think of these paintings as constructed works or imagined works.
I could also go into a discussion of how every painting is constructed, imagined, or abstracted in some way. A camera can take an instant picture of something, freeze the movement of light and shadow in a fraction of a second, whereas the painter has to fix the light source in one place to set shadows and continue painting while the outside light continues to move, which of course makes shadows move as well. The carefully observed painting, then, is a composite of sorts of many observations. Some of those observations, however, are imagined rather than observed. They may be remembered from an initial observation, but they no longer exist and actually will never again exist in the same way. The next day at the same time the sun will not be in the same position in relation to the Earth, and many aspects of a landscape will have changed also – leaves will have fallen, grass will have grown or turned color, flowers may have bloomed or faded – there can be lots of subtle or dramatic changes.
The observation of nature and the changes that happen within it continually shape our thinking about the world that we see and experience. Art grows out of our ways of processing information through the senses. Sense experience is what we know, and we are particularly suited to contemplate this insofar as we can. We are, after all, a curious lot. I suppose some cynical person might say that art is a lot of sophisticated navel gazing, but I think it’s far more than that. There may be a strong element of egoism involved – we do often speak of ourselves as at the top of the food chain, as the intelligent animal, or as the carrier of a soul – all these we see as elevating us above the beasts of the field. And, we make art. No other creature does that.
Posted on 3/21/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Probably for as long as there have been people, there has been a desire for immortality. We can find evidence in ancient cultures in myths and legends of individuals seeking favor of the gods for lengthened life if not outright immortality, which is the provenance of the gods themselves. In myths, as in Ancient Greek tales, the gods looked down on humanity as ‘mere mortals.’ Humans, then, have sought ways to become immortalized, if not physically so, then at least memorialized in some way. They attempted to do things that insured they would be remembered for posterity. One could become a great leader or perform some heroic act, often in battle, that would seal his/her memory for all time. One could invent something of great value to a people or to humanity. One could create art that might be remembered for all time. Any of these could be keys to immortality, at least in historical memory.
Many of the greatest artists have this kind of immortal name recognition. They are usually recognized by one name and that most often is their first name: Rembrandt, Leonardo, Raphael, Titian, or Michelangelo, but for others it is the last name that is remembered: Tintoretto (a nickname), Delacroix, Manet, Monet, or Corot. We continue this tradition in the West as we speak about recent masters like Picasso or Matisse or Bonnard. These names are also synonymous with the highest quality expression if not outright perfection. They are immortalized within the annals of art history and history in general as geniuses of their kind. Whether these artists intended to become immortal in that sense or actively pursued such a thing is questionable. Reaching such a high level of achievement is part of the legend that accompanies such figures.
Perhaps there are some who do actively seek this notoriety. Most of us probably do want to be remembered in some way even if kindly by family and friends. Do we also want to be immortalized, to have our work be such that generations after will continue to learn from and laud what we have done? Some will likely say that it won’t matter after we are gone. What does matter is to do the best we can do day by day and to contribute in whatever ways we can to the wellbeing of others. That can be a good legacy, and there are many people I have known whom I continue to remember because of the effect they had on my life and the lives of others. These are ones I have known personally, but there also are others I did not know who impacted my life as a creative person. All of them in some way are incorporated into the work I do whether it is recognizable or not. Their spirit and influence are part of what I do as an artist. In some small way I am memorializing them as I remember them through my art.
Posted on 3/20/2016 5:19:23 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Rosenquist - Gift-Wrapped Doll
I’ve never cared much for the paintings of James Rosenquist. I could say the same for many of the Pop Art practitioners. I am aware that sometimes there is social criticism, satire, and anti-consumerism as part of some of these works. I’m also aware of the links to different periods of art history and some philosophical perspectives shared with Renaissance painting, Dutch painting, and periods of academic painting. Influences on any artist are always filtered through subjective screens, which is why we can see very different work coming from two artists claiming to have been influenced by the same painter or same type of art.
The images of much Pop Art are not very interesting to me, and their frequent huge scale demands a mural-size induced flatness and simplification that to me is not appealing. I’ve seen many of Rosenquist’s original paintings, so I’m not simply responding to reproduced images that totally distort scale. I’ve also seen at least two versions of the famous F-111 that is often among those images reproduced.
Perhaps the close proximity of much Pop Art to commercial advertising (a world from which Rosenquist came as a billboard painter but also student of art) is part of the issue for me. Perhaps it is the audacity of the large images meant to influence from a distance, not the normal viewing distance of painting (but what is the normal viewing distance of art intended to fill large spaces?). Perhaps it is the kitschy appearance of so much of this kind of painting that annoys me. I do recognize my biases and admit to them.
Currently, though, I’m reading Painting below Zero: Notes on a life in Art by James Rosenquist and David Dalton that a friend loaned to me. Rosenquist’s story is interesting and reminds me of many shared experiences of life during the mid-twentieth century. I understand better where his art come from, that his story is a personal one and not one fabricated by critics to enhance the cachet of a particular art movement. The latter is a specific danger to which western art has been subjected for a great many generations. It is part of the price of living and working within a particular culture. Just as ordinary people are influenced by the machinations of their leaders and others in positions of power, so is everyone influenced by any number of cultural and social forces regardless how independent we may think ourselves.
One group of Rosenquist works I do find interesting and engaging is the series of gift-wrapped dolls from the 1990’s. These images are colorful, well-painted, convincingly illusionistic, and carry a complex metaphorical dimension – the images are portions of the dolls, mostly heads, that appear to be wrapped in cellophane or plastic (as preserved objects rather than gifts since gifts would normally be hidden by wrappers). Dolls are prime examples of consumerism as playthings for children (also often must-have items that can become collectibles, possibly a reference to art). They are stylized figures already, so they are perfect as Pop images. They are symbols of imaginative play while referencing the innocence of childhood. Yet, Rosenquist presents them sometimes in an almost menacing way (no overt reference to Stephen King), perhaps to suggest the indoctrination of children to gender roles or the expectations of parents. Personally, I find these paintings much more satisfying than the grandiose murals that have become icons of the Pop Art movement.
I do applaud Rosenquist for his accomplishments and for his contributions to twentieth century American painting. There are many who do enjoy and appreciate his work. Every artist has the right to follow his or her muse wherever that may lead. Others may or may not follow. It is certain that along the way there will be many critics.
Posted on 3/19/2016 7:57:25 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Typically, a painting (or other work of art) is made for an audience, but in the process of making, the artist probably is not thinking about the audience. A lot is said or written about the artist communicating with his or her audience, but for me, at least, I don’t care about the audience until the work is presented publicly. The painting is for me – it is my experience in the moment with no thought or feeling for whoever may or may not like it.
This mindset is different for writers of certain types of works where an audience needs to be informed, instructed, or persuaded of something. It is different for the commercial artist whose purpose is to sell an idea, product, or the work itself. I know this goes against what many today say when advising artists how to sell, to focus on a market need or to carve out a niche market and cater to that. In my mind, though, the work that is produced is strictly commercial.
Many artists think more or less as I do and struggle in some way to stay true to their artistic concerns, values, or aesthetic (however they may think about these) while also working to market the finished products. There are so many different views about this, and every artist has to decide for him or herself how to play the art game. Ultimately, art is a product and artists desire to make a living to be able to keep making art.
I went to a gallery today to see a show of paintings by some so-called ‘early’ abstract painters from Houston: Jack Boynton, Dorothy Hood, Dick Wray, Charles Schorre, and a few others. Some of these artists taught in various settings during the seventies and eighties. Some showed widely around the country and even internationally. Others were known regionally. Most of the galleries that showed their works are now gone. All these artists, though, were exploring abstraction and helping in their way to establish Houston as an art center. Their individual successes varied.
Most of them did strong work – it was interesting, unique, and related in some ways to abstract painting done elsewhere whether color field, expressionist, or just intensely personal. They created a Houston art scene but not a particular Houston style. They were too individualistic. Most of the work, however, if compared to that of bigger names, holds its own, for all these painters mastered their craft. They held true to their principles and personal visions. Isn’t this what most artists want to be said of them?
Posted on 3/18/2016 6:57:02 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I watched part of a film about the Mona Lisa yesterday on PBS. The film is several years old, probably is accessible on YouTube, but I had not seen it previously. One of the most intriguing parts to me (there are many mysteries, of course, surrounding this painting) was the use of carbon dating to test pigments used in a second Mona Lisa, an unfinished one, believed to either have been painted by Leonardo or painted in his workshop. I won’t include any spoilers here in case someone has not yet seen the film – and I haven’t seen all of it – for I’m most interested in how much is continually invested in the study of world art heritage.
Carbon dating has been used for some time in archaeological and anthropological studies, especially prehistoric studies, geological study, ecological study, and certain historical applications. It is less often used in the study of paintings although this may be changing as forgers improve their copying techniques and more complex issues of attribution arise. Technology in use today in the field of art conservation is impressive to say the least and incredibly expensive. If anyone questions the validity of art, its importance to society, and people’s willingness to do whatever it takes to preserve and protect our mutual heritage, they are obviously ignorant of the vast resources committed regularly for this very purpose.
One scene in the film shows a researcher removing a microscopic sample from the painting, encasing it in resin, and then studying it under high-power microscopy. Samples are also carbon dated to verify that the materials used (pigments and canvas or wood support) are from the time period that Leonardo was working. I understand that the laboratory where the carbon dating is done is not solely for the purpose of dating artwork. Even so, the vastness of the space, the complexity of the equipment, and the enormous price tag that goes with it, mean that a test of this nature is itself extremely expensive. This is solely for the purpose of gathering information and answering questions about one painting. It has nothing to do with the care of the painting in question, another area where expense will, no doubt, not be spared. In fact, that suspected second Leonardo Mona Lisa, which is owned by a group of investors, is kept deep in a secret vault under constant armed guard at an undisclosed location somewhere in Switzerland.
For the average person this may either mean nothing or may incite him or her to anger over the (to that person) misuse of vast sums of money for colored pigment on a piece of weathered wood. Why waste this money when people are starving or dying from lack of food and water elsewhere in the world? Are we raising moral issues here? How does art affect the average man in the street? It may be one thing to display a painting like the Mona Lisa so that those who are able can actually see it should they choose to do so. To that end the museum charged with its care has a moral obligation to protect the work even though the public has no stake in it (the Louvre’s Mona Lisa sits behind bullet-proof glass – it was, after all, once stolen from the museum).
The study and preservation of art, its presentation to an adoring public in museums and galleries around the world, is hugely big business. Never mind that many museum collections have grown from works once stolen from countries of origin in the name of finders keepers or from donations of private collections or from public monies raised by museums for the purchase of specific works. Some private museums like the Menil Collection in Houston or the Sterling and Francine Clark Collection in Williamstown, Massachusetts also house priceless works and are open to the public just like regular museums (if any museum can be called that). Thank goodness for these socially minded collectors and public institutions or works would be hidden away like the privately held Mona Lisa.
How do we even begin to address value when speaking about any work of art, well known or otherwise? Our collective judgment may not always be trustworthy, and any one group may decide on its own to obliterate that which it deems unworthy for whatever reason (the Taliban, for example, with the great carved Buddhas in Afghanistan). This question of artistic value will always be unresolved as long as societies continue to bicker over the value of human life.
Posted on 3/17/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Painting is a visual art that is built from visual language (images) rather than words. Writers obviously use words to create their art, but they can be very descriptive and evocative and can create mental images for the reader that can seem very real. There are words that appeal to the senses or various forms of figurative language that aid the writer to achieve whatever effects he or she may desire. A painter does not use words. His arsenal includes shapes and colors and textures. With these the adept painter will create contrasts that make images appear as they do. Everything is visual rather than verbal.
I find the work and thinking of German painter Gerhard Richter interesting to ponder. Among other things he has said, “Painting is the making of an analogy for something non-visual and incomprehensible – giving it form and bringing it within reach. And that is why good paintings are incomprehensible.” In spite of noting that painting is visual and something always is lost when trying to describe it, we continue to attempt to describe. Why do we do this? Why do we write so much or say so much about something that has to be seen, has to be experienced by directly seeing it in order to understand it? We are trying to explain something about this experience to ourselves. We can listen to music and experience its sound, which evokes all sorts of emotional and perhaps even intellectual responses, and we may attempt to describe something about our feelings or responses even when we know that what really matters is the act of hearing the music. The only way to experience anything like that is to hear it again.
I believe the same is true for painting. We see it and respond to it in the moment. We may carry away visual images in the mind just as we can hear music after the fact in the mind’s ear, so to speak, but these are only snippets and mental fictions. Perhaps to anchor something of these visual or audial experiences, we talk or write about them and use our words like some kind of web to hold on to some part of that experience. We never, however, seem quite to grasp the art outside of its presence. We come back to it later, the music or the painting, and re-experience the feeling from before and say, “Ah, yes, that was it – that color or that sound,” but we don’t have to say it because we feel it, see it, sense it, and merge with it in the moment. The outward physicality of the work will always be there to return to when we choose, and soon we discover that upon returning we might surprisingly think that the art has changed. We see or hear things that we did not see or hear before. Ultimately, we realize that it is not the art that has changed, but it is we that have changed, for we have been changed by the art. It is teaching us through our response to it.
I find this is true for me when responding to the work of other artists. I find this is true for me when responding to work of my own. This is one of many realizations that brings me back to art again and again.
Posted on 3/16/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Art and science are frequently seen as somewhat opposing disciplines. Generally, this is because art is considered largely subjective and science is supposed to be based on objectivity. Since both are human endeavors, however, we can easily demonstrate that scientists can be subjective in their judgments just as artists can be objective when they might choose to be. Or, we could take an authoritarian stance and conclude that everything is subjective. Therefore science only gives the appearance of objectivity, but that is a bit extreme in my view.
Science works because there is a built-in process of verification. If an opinion is stated, it must be backed up with facts and evidence that are verifiable and results that are duplicable. Some other party should be able to repeat an experiment or take some action previously taken and produce the same results. We see all kinds of mechanical processes that are the result of scientific principles directly applied. Think, for example, about manufacturing standards that are followed to guarantee the quality of certain products. This becomes critical in the manufacture of drugs and medications, but we also see the process working with clothing, cars, foods, and other manufactured goods. We also see what happens when manufacturers cut corners by using cheaper materials that inevitably lower quality of the products.
There are immediate parallels in the arts. Art materials including paints, solvents, grounds, and a great variety of other materials can be high or low quality, the choice of which will affect the resultant art. The best quality materials, however, do not guarantee the highest quality art. The artist is where real quality control begins. The artist first makes choice of materials. As important, or possibly more importantly, is how the artist handles the materials in the manufacture of the art, if we may use that term to describe the art making process.
Let’s assume that the artist has utilized the best materials available (although I suspect we’ll find many, possibly a majority, who do not). Let’s also assume that the artist follows meticulous procedures in the handling of the materials: preparation, working conditions, application, appropriate stage development, care in handling, and preservation. As a manufactured good, the resultant art may be considered high quality, for it is sound in every physical aspect. The catch, of course, is whether the work also has high artistic quality, and that is where a huge subjective gray area exists. Debates over this gray area have raged for centuries and probably will continue for centuries to come since the quality control is much more lax here than in the sciences.
The ultimate defining decision about art is a subjective one. There may be widespread agreement, but that is still subjective. We can cite examples of artists whose work was generally ignored in their own time only to be “discovered” and lauded well after their deaths. General agreement was not in favor of the artist while living, but later general agreement acknowledges that the artist is exceptional. Similarly, artists also fall out of favor. There is nothing new in this.
From the artist’s perspective, he or she may emulate another highly respected artist’s work or aesthetic, may follow a particular movement or style, may follow market demands and trends, may follow an inner voice, or may attempt to build a style (brand) that identifies him or her as uniquely recognizable – Rembrandt, Monet, Cezanne, Matisse, Chagall, and on – the list could be quite extensive. There are so many variables at work (Fine Art, popular art, realism, abstraction, academic, traditional, cultural, historical, critical, high brow, low brow…) that the process becomes quite confusing. The artist may decide what art is made, but how that work is received is at the mercy of other forces.
Science, on the other hand, is somewhat more restrained. There may still be jockeying for status and power among scientists, but there are tests for what works and what doesn’t. Results have to be borne out by the scientific method. Art is at the whim of cultural attitudes, the market place, and personal biases. Art by its very nature will always be subjective. Were it ever to become primarily objective, we would no longer call it art.
Posted on 3/15/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Clarity and sense are two guiding words for written communication. A message, no matter how beautifully written, is ultimately of limited use unless it is clearly communicated. Take poetry as an example. Its purpose partly is to obfuscate, to be beautiful and seductive, to provide multiple meanings and possibilities, but not to provide clarity, at least not overall. That would defeat its larger purpose as a work of art. The highest art is filled with richness that may include clarity in parts but not clarity overall. Any work that is fully explained loses some of its mystery and power.
Of course we do not expect everyday communications to be art though we may speak of communication itself as an art. What we generally mean by that use of the word art, however, is that we must craft communications for specific clarity to ensure that they make sense to the intended audience. By comparison, art in whatever form has a limited audience though some artists may attempt to reach the broadest possible audience. Those works fall into the area called popular art, and with popular art one of the main purposes is entertainment. Therefore, its ability to communicate is paramount. As a result, clarity takes on greater importance in its creation.
In Shakespeare’s day, he and other playwrights included coarse jokes and comic characters in tragedies to appeal to the less educated among the audience who might not respond to the loftier verse that often dealt with philosophical and spiritual themes. The artistic craft of these writers and many who have come after them was such that readers and audiences continue to argue meaning today. Hundreds of books and articles have been written explaining this or that aspect of particular works. This continues with the highest art forms across many disciplines. Much is communicated, certainly, but the communication is neither direct nor always clear in these art works. We explain this by identifying an artist’s particular vision (his or her interpretation of art and the world) or speak about artistic license to justify anything that may deviate from the norm.
The wise artist will not create something unintelligible to the audience. That also would defeat its purpose as art. Art needs to be appreciated; it needs its audience. The artist may provide some way in for the audience, but there may also be many secret chambers to which keys must be discovered to unlock their secrets. Each artist creates these according to his or her purpose, intention, and creative ability. Those with many secrets may be those that last the longest.
Posted on 3/14/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

A sundial works because the shadow that is cast by the gnomon, the usually angled piece that rises perpendicular to the base, tracks the movement of the sun. We’ve all noticed striking shadows cast by trees, people, or other objects on bight days. Sometimes the shadows make very interesting shapes that can be more interesting than the objects that cast them. Landscape painters, especially plein air painters, have to pay close attention to shadows because of the dramatic change that can occur within the hour or so that it may take to complete a painting. The shadows have to be consistent within the picture or else the painter will be accused of sloppiness and inattention to detail.
Out in the real world a shadow is only a visual phenomenon. It has no substance. We recognize this and use the term metaphorically when we say that someone is a mere shadow of his former self or describe a devil or ghost as a character with no shadow or reflection because they are not in corporeal form. A shadow is not an illusion but is the absence of light. It conforms to the surface upon which it is cast and is dependent on whatever blocks the light (and the intensity and angle of the light) for its basic shape. In a painting, however, an insubstantial shadow is as substantial as anything else. In fact, objects or space around objects are simply shapes on the surface of the canvas. All are dependent on the physical quality of the paint to project the illusion of substance or void, object or shadow.
As viewers, we interpret what a painter has created as a certain kind of image. It closely relates to observed reality or it does not. A painter may take liberty – in fact has to take liberty while painting something with moving shadows – with what is observed in order to make the painting believable and “true to life.” An abstract painter is not bound by the same restrictions, but he or she still must manipulate colors and forms to create whatever visual and emotional impact is posed for the viewer.
What an artist has to do to adjust color to suggest that an area is in shadow (generally tinting colors with blue or purple or neutral tones) is not too different from what he does to create the effect of transparency (utilizing a local color like the green of glass to tint or alter the color of an object that is “seen” behind it). In both cases the artist is employing color to do the work and create an illusion, but does the illusion lie in the painting or in the eye of the beholder? Certainly a painting has to be seen to be appreciated, so it, as an object external to viewer, is dependent upon the viewer for its success. The relatively thin veil of paint, sometimes as sheer as a shadow, creates its magic first through the eye and hand of the painter and then through the eye of the viewer. The shadow of reality that is created lies somewhere in between and exists within the mind of both.
Posted on 3/13/2016 6:57:04 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I begin new classes tomorrow in Written Communication. Typically I find that most students have difficulty with writing partly because they have not learned the necessary basics of grammar and organization of ideas. Some have challenges prioritizing ideas, thinking of things to say, or imagining what a reader might need to know about a topic. Writing about something is not that different from talking about it except that a writer needs to explain and support statements that he or she makes. This is true regardless of subject, and many people know more than they think they know but just don’t know how to communicate that.
There was an earlier period in my life as a producing artist when my focus was on abstract painting (as it is now). During this time I put together a number of one-man shows and participated in many group exhibits. My work sold reasonably well, which was gratifying, but I’ve tended to be more motivated by the reaction of viewers as I would dialogue with them in the gallery or the studio. Fortunately, my audience has always included an abundance of supportive friends, some of them creative people in their own right, but most of them don’t think of themselves as creative. Word of mouth from these friends and advertising in local media often generated quite diverse groups of attendees at these various art events. To the people I didn’t know, I didn’t always introduce myself first thing; I wanted to hear what they might say about the work unhindered. To me their responses were often enlightening; for example, how close they frequently were in expressing their feelings to what I had felt when creating the painting. If I introduced myself first and then asked how they liked the show or a certain piece, a discomforting look might appear on their brow. Something might be mumbled in embarrassment.
A typical response from someone unused to talking about art is “I don’t know much about art, so I don’t feel qualified to say,” or “I’ve never thought much about painting,” or “I’d rather hear what you have to say about it.” It’s always tempting to jump right in and explain every nuance of my esthetic theory. The old saying, though, that what’s interesting to you might not be interesting to someone else, is very useful to remember at those times. My response, then, is to ask a few questions. I might say, “I’m not sure my work communicates my intention. Do you mind if I ask you a few questions?” Most people will readily agree. Then I might ask them what they first felt when they looked at the painting. Depending on their response, I might ask them to tell me more. I probe for clarification if the response is too general, but my experience has been that most people, even the reticent ones, are very aware of their feelings: they’re attracted, confused, annoyed, interested, intrigued, put off, mystified, angry, and so on. Another question or two and they will speak what they know including the reasons why. Sometimes they are becoming aware of this as they speak. When appropriate, I connect something they say to something that is true for me about the piece in question. We continue dialoging about the painting almost as if we are two artists intently discussing art over coffee at a local café. Here and there I compliment them on their perceptiveness. The same process can be utilized talking about representational work, which often leads us beyond talking about what the painting represents into what the painting might mean. Most art is, after all, symbolic expression.
Whether viewers become buyers or not, they have given me the pleasure of knowing their appreciation, and, hopefully, I’ve given them validation of their own experience. This they can take to the next show and the next artist, but more than once I’ve had someone call me later and say, “You know, I’m really interested in that painting we discussed. Is it still available?”
Posted on 3/12/2016 10:44:49 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

At school I’m teaching in a department that has four week classes, part of a nine month program for the students. Basically every month I see a new set of students and work with them for that module of class. Sometimes I teach the same students several different courses. Since many of the students are young, often recently out of high school, their level of maturity is still very much adolescent. I am reminded of my own arrogant youth.
I hate to admit it, but there was a period of time when I was not a very good student. High school was a tumultuous time filled with the desire to fit in, longing to escape the confines of home, fear of being doomed to mediocrity, and general uncertainty about the future. Art was not particularly on my mind even though sometimes I rather egotistically thought myself to be some singularly great creative genius. That was part of the fantasy I carried around in my head while actually creating a fairly conservative high school career that did include involvement in a variety of clubs, organizations, and social circles. All of this I dropped right after graduation, which began my period of rebellion.
My choice to pursue art rather than engineering was a challenging one but one I’ve never regretted. What I do regret is my attitude for several years during this transitional phase. No one could tell me what was true. I knew the truth, and I pontificated often upon my version of it. I ignored my teachers, rankled under their criticism, and wasted a good deal of time and their energy spent trying to wake me up. Eventually I did wake up and began to learn how to learn. This is when I also began to understand the real power and significance of art.
Being an artist, for me, is about an attitude, not an egotistical posture of ‘being an artist.’ It is about coming from a mindset that the world is a miraculous place that is endlessly, creatively expressive – creation, transformation, destruction, revitalization – all of these ongoing processes that constitute life. In some small way, the artist emulates this creative process of change and renewal in order, I think, to simply appreciate and express appreciation for what is so abundantly around us. I hope that in some small way I can impart my insight to the students I encounter with regularity regardless of subject.
Posted on 3/11/2016 8:21:22 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Interruptions are part of life. The unexpected event is always there as possibility, as potential energy that can be positive or negative. We cannot read the future, but we all carry past experience in the form of memories and feelings. We have learned to accept most of these interruptions in stride, and as we mature, we learn to utilize skills and experience to address the more serious unexpected challenges when they occur.
In the process of making a painting, encourage interruptions within a composition. I’m not necessarily thinking of these as metaphorical expressions related to life experience, but they could be. I am interested in a line moving across the surface that disappears and then reappears on another side of the picture plane. Its directional movement has been interrupted by a shape or series of shapes or other lines. Our perceptive ability to see connection, what psychologists call closure, enables us to experience the line as complete, as though it still exists behind whatever appears to obscure it. This is an interpretation, of course, since there could be two separate lines that only appear to connect across some distance. Our perception can be described as ambiguous – we can see one line that has been interrupted or we can see two lines that exist within the same plane.
Again, this could relate to life experience because there are circumstances or events that appear ambiguous. As compositional devices, however, appearance and disappearance, continuity or closure, are interesting and enjoyable to play with and are useful in most styles of painting under the larger categories of realistic or abstract. The repetition of colors throughout a painting is a similar device that forms a kind of visual echo or rhyme much like what can be seen in tapestries where threads of color weave in and out of a composition. Certain colors that may localize into a shape or object in one part of the image can be randomly scattered hints of color elsewhere as the thread continues in the warp or weft of the weaving.
What may first appear as an interruption, then, may not be one at all. It is actually an integrated part of the overall design that likely will become apparent as the perceptive viewer studies a painted image. Depending on the nature of the apparent disruption, the effect of space, rhythm, directional movement, or repetition may be suggested. Add the possibility of metaphorical meaning and we have the makings of complex composition from simple means.
Posted on 3/10/2016 5:32:07 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Structure versus no structure; orderly versus randomly; rhythmical versus erratic. Are each of these contrasting pairs elements of art? Are all of these found in nature? Some have said that the seemingly random is simply that which has not yet been identified as having order – or, the order has not been identified. This is understandable for things very large (thinking on a cosmic scale where discoveries are still being made in the broader universe) or things very small (the microcosmically small where scientists have delved deeper into the subatomic level). I am reminded of the novel The Incredible Shrinking Man from the 1950s and how the main character realizes that he won’t shrink into oblivion. He will just continue to shrink infinitely, and thus will inhabit a certain scale world for a time until he gradually shrinks into another level of being. This is another way of imagining that there is the undiscovered awaiting to be discovered. But, is discovery of some pattern or regularity or orderliness simply an imposition of the human mind programmed as it is to perceive order? And, is this a major reason that we find art so intriguing as a means of expression since it is largely about creating order?
These I find intriguing questions that likely have no definitive answers. Within the realm of art, artists continually raise questions or pose answers to longstanding questions, answers that often expand our understanding and expand our perceptive abilities about being. In other words, artists give answers that open new possibilities. What better way is there to contemplate our interaction with the world or with our own minds? Artists inspire new ways of seeing and thinking and these can touch every other aspect of being human from microcosm to macrocosm. Within this realm of possibilities, the irregular may become regular or may be given a form of regularity just as the regular may dissolve or expand into irregularity. These create even more possibility for exploration. How, then, can art ever grow stale or inconsequential when there is so much promise unfulfilled?
Posted on 3/9/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

In Western painting from roughly 1300 to well into the 1800s, painting was done with uniform texture. There are notable exceptions like Franz Hals or Rembrandt and possibly preparatory sketches done by many painters that might show brushwork. Mostly, though, paintings are executed so that paint texture is not noticeable. The intention seems to be for the paint to disappear as it creates the image – what many have referred to as a painting being a window on reality. The image is judged by its verisimilitude and how lifelike the subject is portrayed. This perhaps reached its peak during the Dutch Golden Age, which is also when we find Hals and Rembrandt at work, decidedly powerful realist painters but also ones who relished the surface texture of paint and brushstrokes.
All students of art history are familiar with the shift that occurs as painters in the mid-1800s begin to experiment with direct painting methods, some suggest following the invention of the paint tube and portable paints that allowed artists to work directly outdoors. However that shift came about, once it happened for many there was no going back. In fact, most likely the sea change that develops through experimentation and the redefining of what a painting is (or seems to be, or is conceived to be by the individual artist), may be the direct result of Impressionisms influence coupled with the declining influence of the art academies. There can be lots of debate over these and other transitional ideas, but many artists today will advocate for personal discretion in how work is created and where emphasis is placed.
As an artist – I should say as an appreciator of art – I have very eclectic taste. I love the idea of creative expression and the joy of creative variety. It is remarkable what artists regardless of culture, nationality, or social constraints can do with objects and images. In my own learning process as both artist and student of art, I’ve explored a wide range of approaches and styles mainly to better understand the creative process. My current work tend sot be abstract and highly textured, but there are many artists I admire who work in what can be called traditional styles and use traditional painting methods. What ultimately matters to me is that work is well executed and crafted.
Posted on 3/8/2016 9:01:52 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

The world of nature is filled with powerful forces that impact us in countless ways. We ignore much of that when reclining beneath a tree on a warm summer afternoon (those of us that have the leisure for such pastime). At least I can remember some of those lazy times from childhood when I was also ignorant of the forces at play all around me. Now I know more about the forces and feel their effects more acutely with age as well as understand how these glorious elements that surround us and bind us to our natural world not only serve to motivate us but also serve to pressure us into a form of submission that we choose to call adaptation. In some ways artists mimic these forces as they create their art, for every creative act is a range of energetic expression that includes mental, physical, and emotional energies converging within the resultant art.
There can be pleasure in the intellectual side of art making, thinking about art and aesthetics, theorizing about beauty or truth, appreciating the long historical march of artistic expression, and trying to make cogent sense of incredibly diverse talents and creations. Museums are built around this legacy. There also, however, is an emotional side, a physical pleasure that comes from feeling rather than words, from sense rather than intellect. That is the energy of nature that comes through the art and to which a great many respond without knowing why or how. That emotional aspect is always part of every creative act that I have undertaken, for if it were missing, the creative act would never move to completion. It needs that life energy to birth itself and grow into its aesthetic form.
Posted on 3/7/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Completeness – wholeness – movement towards completion: all of these have tremendous human appeal. Is the appeal of art, therefore, largely in its presentation of completion, much like an ode to completion? Through art life is depicted in orderly, organized, and complete segments – Gestalt moments. But, life is a process that is messy and not particularly organized in the way that we might choose. We respond to the seeming order of nature, but even here it is continually varied. Days are not exactly the same length. The position or movement of the sun is slightly different day to day, plus changing atmospheric conditions affect the amount of light, ambient temperature, humidity, and other factors. Nothing is ever repeated the same way even though the general movement is rhythmical. We misperceive regularity and call that normalcy and say that life is predictable when it isn’t. The cynic will say that we are born and we will die; we just don’t know when the latter will happen. The optimist says that each day is new and full of opportunity.
Art is a construct, but so is our perception of the world. Art can be controlled, ordered, given a resolution and completion. Life has too many variables, quite a few of which we may not even be aware. We create, therefore, as a coping or survival mechanism, the semblance of order. We compartmentalize our work, our play, our day to day activities, and we call it normal and natural. Art represents to some degree our sense of control, our longing for completion and wholeness and meaning. This can be true today and tomorrow we may choose differently. Life is like that too – changeable, but after all, we are expressions of life, so why shouldn’t flux be part of our expression as well?
Completion is fundamental to our existence as organisms. Bodily processes move in cycles from the smallest cell to the larger whole. We cannot breathe in without breathing out. Our blood cells circulate throughout our bodies carrying nutrients and oxygen to each part and carrying away waste to be eliminated from the body. If the process breaks down, we die. We relate to the world through our senses, and the sensations we turn into perceptions. We do this continually until we can do it no more. Even our thoughts, which we so greatly pride ourselves on, are dependent on processes that we do not fully perceive, do not feel, and do not really control. They are largely automatic, yet from these we create our consciousness and sense of self. The completeness of each level of life process is necessary to our wellbeing. Perhaps we are programmed also to act creatively but in a self-conscious way. Thus, our predilection for order as expressed in art and in our attempts to create order within our lives may be another pulse of life beating in ways that compel us to do but which we cannot fully grasped like the physician who can count the breaths and measure the heart’s rhythm but cannot instill breath or command the heart to beat.
We may feel compelled to make art, to appreciate art, and to see ourselves in art (or compelled to experience something else the same way many experience art – sports, science, or other human expressions, for example). We have to express in this way to stay sane just as we have to breathe in order to remain living. There is completion is this activity on many levels, so it should not be surprising that the majority of art is about completion, expresses completion, and is the product of completion. If our search for meaning is at heart a search for order, as it seems to be whether expressed by faith or by reason, we find evidence from the tiniest known quantity to the most grandiose, and we recognize that our physical selves manifest according to the order of our DNA. Heraclitus once observed that all is flux, but what is flux but a movement toward completion?
Posted on 3/6/2016 6:20:20 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I was at a dinner with work colleagues recently at a popular Tex-Mex restaurant. We were all in good mood telling each other stories of aspects of our lives that were similar in experience though none of us knew each other when we experienced those things. I had just been served a bowl of tortilla soup, which was delicious. It contained cubes of avocado, pulled chicken, slices of corn on the cob, fried tortilla strips, with a side of grated cheese that would melt into a pleasing goo when sprinkled into the hot broth. Someone was talking about a fear of driving over high bridges, how she would go miles out of her way to avoid them, when an inch long roach crawled from beneath my plate. I could tell he was curious, perhaps at the abundant smells that confused his sense of direction, perhaps at the insistent and overly loud pop music (not even Mexican) in the background, or perhaps embarrassed at having been seen. For a second or two I considered what to do. Should I catch him in a napkin and complain to the waiter? Should I smack him with a fork? Should I exclaim and draw everyone’s attention to this intruder? Or, should I quietly dispense with him so no one else would know? Why disrupt the meal and gross out the ladies?
I elected to unobtrusively brush him from the table since I didn’t want a squashed bug spoiling my dinner or anyone else’s. However, several thoughts came to mind that could be potential narratives. The roach could become a character in a mini-drama. He had set out that morning from the parking lot rock under which he lived to embark on a great journey that had been inhabiting his thoughts much like a scratched record repeating a song lyric over and over. Get out of the city it told him, go to the country where there is less stress and more quiet. No more dodging the erratic feet of overly-fed diners who had had too many margaritas. No more scurrying amidst the soggy crumbs scattered throughout the parking lot or scaling the dizzying heights of the greasy garbage cans. By way of preparation he went into the restaurant earlier than usual not knowing that special arrangements were under way for a large party that evening. While rushing across the one large expanse of floor that exposed him to potential injury or worse, he did not see the dropped biscuit that rolled in his direction. Three quarters of the way across the floor and within sprinting distance of his favorite table, he was sideswiped by the rolling biscuit. His legs buckled and he half tumbled, half skidded toward the metal leg of the table, caught his footing again but not before crashing headlong against the gray metal tube. He slipped into a dream of flowers and grasses and quietly rustling leaves.
Any experience can become fodder for artistic reverie. The artist then must choose what to do with the thought or feeling and craft it however seems best. That, however, is the exciting thing about being an artist. There is so much possibility.
Posted on 3/5/2016 5:05:50 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

I catch myself thinking sometimes that artists or writers do certain things either in the making of their art or in the many tasks associated with that making. For example, I might think that writers make notes in journals about their experiences or thoughts on a regular basis. It is from notes that stories or essays or lengthy written considerations and theoretical discussions may develop. That seems like a reasonable statement to make, but what I really know for certain is that a few writers I’ve read about may do these things, some writers giving advice to other writers say to do these things, or I personally do some variation on these things in my own creative process. It is easy to make general statements based on one’s personal beliefs, but these may not apply to others and what they do. To be precise in language (and dare I say that most artists are precise in their creative activities?), it is important to speak accurately about what is known from personal experience. I try to do this in my blogs, for I am writing mostly about my own experience and artistic concerns mainly to keep a record of my thinking on various art-related topics such as the current one.
My concern here is how I use drawing as a creative tool. I’m not so much interested in cataloging the many ways I may use drawing or how other artists use or have used drawing. My focus is on a current series of drawings done either with graphite or with colored pencil. I may also use some kind of pen or marker in combination with either of these tools. In the past I’ve gone through periods where I created mostly brush drawings, and I may explore this medium again possibly adding color with watercolor pencils or straight watercolor. Whatever the particular medium, though, these current drawings are continuing the theme of windows and doors I’ve pursued in oil paintings.
These current drawings, however, though related thematically to the paintings, are not preparatory studies for paintings. Rather, they are studies of the thematic expression in the given drawing medium of the moment. This means employing accumulated lines to create areas of color or value instead of traditional shading techniques (I can imagine doing this more effectively in charcoal drawings but as yet have not done so). Still I can achieve similar effects of layered color and visual texture by crisscrossing lines and overlaying shapes or linear elements. One difference is that in the drawings line is the main carrier of information. Also, in the drawings I make use of the paper ground as an integral part of the image (much like in watercolor painting). Sometimes I employ a straight edge or templates to create contrast with fluid and erratic lines. Erasers have also become important drawing tools to blend, delete or partially delete lines or areas of color. The resultant layering of these elements creates a complex image with many levels of depth and visual surface texture.
I do sometimes think of these drawings as doodles with purpose. Usually when I begin I have only the vaguest notion of where a drawing may go. The drawing process is very spontaneous, and I am continually responding to the marks just made for clues to what is to be done next. I could say that the process followed in developing a drawing is organic. It begins with a seed mark that grows into its mature and somewhat unpredictable outcome. Even so, there is thematic unity that runs through just over one hundred drawings completed thus far.
Posted on 3/4/2016
By Donald Fox
1 Comment

A painting is a metaphor for itself. What does this mean exactly? Metaphor is a term or expression that compares something with another thing that is not normally like it. For example, a social butterfly is a person who flits about in a social setting from person to person much like a butterfly moves from flower to flower. There is always an implicit comparison contained within a metaphor if the comparison is not directly stated. Shakespeare wrote “all the world’s a stage,” which is explicitly stated, something is something else. We might speak of someone drunk with love or use filthy money in a discussion of politics, both forms of implicit comparisons. So, how is a painting a metaphor for itself?
First, painting is a process whereby layers of pigment are applied to a surface to achieve desired effects. A completed painting is a physical object that also contains or illustrates certain ideas or principles depending on the purpose of the artist. We can describe a painting in terms of what image it represents, i.e. a portrait, a landscape, or an abstract design. That image is composed of those paint elements (pigment and surface) mentioned before. The arrangement of the elements follows design principles (form, line, shape, color and its characteristics, and so on), and their use or modification by the artist determines the resultant image, what we might call realistic or abstract or some combination of both.
Artists do include visual metaphors in their paintings often symbolically. A lone tree standing on a hill can represent resilience and strength, or it could represent isolation. A path curving over a hill or disappearing into woods could represent possibility, seeking the unknown, or life’s journey. Many styles of painting include symbols that denote something other than what the illustrated object is. We have come to understand and accept this aspect of art whether expressed in painting, dance, theater, music, or literature. It is also frequently said that art is a metaphor for life. Even abstract painting can express emotional content, natural processes, and sophisticated ideas.
A painting, therefore, is a physical object, a form of personal expression (which may include aesthetic, spiritual, social, or political ideology), a visual image (realistic or abstract), and one of the oldest art forms. A painting always exists as itself (its physical form) and as part of artistic/cultural history (its aesthetic/philosophical form). A painting, then, is an idea; a painting is art; a painting is physical and non-physical simultaneously. A painting is a painting, and a painting is a metaphor for itself.
Posted on 3/3/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Anyone most likely has had the experience of doing something with which he or she is very familiar and what is needed to happen just doesn’t go the way it should. When working alone, the person can struggle along and hope to eventually figure out what is wrong or simply choose to do something else. An athlete not performing well in a game will likely be benched by the coach, a surgeon might ask another surgeon, if available, to step in and finish, but a teacher or a speaker is the sole person in charge and has to think on his or her feet quickly not to lose the audience. In the studio, a painter can have an off day and decide to draw or work on framing or clean the space instead of continuing to paint poorly. While demonstrating, however, this same painter would feel quite embarrassed if a painting turned out poorly. This is why those that do demonstrate practice what they will do until it is second nature.
We don’t normally think of painting as a performing art since work is mostly done away from the eye of the public. What counts is the resultant painting. Any plein air painter may feel challenged by onlookers especially the inquisitive ones who want to know why this or that stroke was made. This situation may certainly be encountered with any public painting. For this reason some painters either will not paint publicly, will choose locations far away from public traffic, or will simply take a break from working until the onlooker becomes bored and retreats.
Whether in public or in private, however, the painter may come up against that resistance or barrier that is preventing work from moving forward successfully. This is when a decision has to be made whether to continue, to stop, or to totally redo what has been done. In other words, to start over. The decision requires self-awareness and critical sensitivity. The decision threshold will be different for every painter. The seasoned painter will most probably continue by calling upon critical faculties to sort out the challenge and make whatever changes are necessary. Achieving that level of proficiency and perception can be a very long and arduous process in itself.
I can remember many frustrating times as a student when I just wanted to throw down my brushes and never paint again. The emotions, thankfully, eventually cooled and I would be back at the easel the next day if not sooner. I also learned to take breaks, and it was particularly soothing to look at work by favorite artists. By looking critically I could usually see something that was beneficial for what I needed to do. For many of us, painting does not come easily, and we learn that perseverance and patience are two important attributes to cultivate.
Posted on 3/2/2016 2:39:09 PM
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

Many years ago in an art class, I worked slavishly on a painting assignment. The process was slow, and I became self-conscious when I realized the instructor was standing behind me watching what I was doing. I became a bit nervous thinking about whether each decision and stroke I made were ones that he might make. Finally, as I stood looking at the mess before me, he stepped up and put a hand on my shoulder. “Relax,” he said. “Don’t be afraid to cover up what’s already there. If you worry about losing something, you won’t get anything else right. Trust your observation and trust the process.”
I’ve thought about those words many times while working on my own paintings. I also find myself thinking of them as I watch students struggling with their painted images. Novice students often paint as though they want the image to pop out on the first or second stroke. They want to paint everything at once without respect to the demands of the medium. They try to short circuit the process.
Painting is a process. The general approach is to start thin and thicken as you go. Whether the paint becomes very thick or not, the basic idea with oil painting is that it is done in layers. Things do get covered up. They’re supposed to; it’s part of the process. The comfort that some may take in a carefully placed drawing often turns to frustration as a painting progresses. The tyranny of those explicit lines becomes restrictive and results in what might be called coloring book paintings. So much time and care is spent trying to paint inside the lines that color and edges suffer, and harmony is lost. The resultant painting is little more than a colored drawing.
I don’t mean to imply that meticulous painting is not good painting. Certainly, meticulous painters like Durer or Ingres produced masterpieces with regularity. They did so because they understood the painting process and how to make it serve their visions. My guess, though, is that most painters are not meticulous painters. Their intent has more to do with expressive, impressionistic, or loosely painted images that allow for flexibility, response to changing light conditions, or discoveries that may not have been anticipated at the outset. However, style is not the issue. That a painting proceeds according to certain steps is the issue at hand, and those steps include covering up something that was previously painted.
Oil paint is designed to show its best qualities when applied in successive layers. Artists understood that oils tend towards transparency over time. The idea of underpainting was used by painters for hundreds of years to enhance the appearance of the end product. The warm, glowing light associated with Rembrandt’s painting is the result of warm, light values painted first in areas where illumination was most desired. His paintings often have a luminosity that verges on the magical. Most of the Flemish painters used layering to achieve a wide range of textural effects in complex still life paintings, portraiture, and interior scenes. Only in the 19th century did painters begin to experiment with layering in ways that did not rely so much on traditional thin layers and glazing. Plein air painting required a more direct approach and wet into wet techniques became staples in the painter’s arsenal.
Direct painting as practiced by plein air painters and others doesn’t eliminate layering. The technique is simply modified in various ways. Some painters will tone their boards or canvases ahead of time with warm, cool, or neutral tones so as to be prepared for various conditions. Some will thinly paint an image rather than create an outline drawing, and then work heavier applications of color into the thin paint. Appropriately placed lighter or darker accents may then come on top of these. One friend of mine loosely covers the canvas with medium to dark paint thinned with oil medium rather than turp, and then uses a rag to wipe certain areas that will be lighter in the composition. He then proceeds with thicker applications of color. The variety of possibilities may not be endless with direct painting, but they certainly are sufficient to meet the creative applications of most artists.
One piece of advice that I’ve heard many times from many sources is to get rid of the white background. It is very difficult to see color accurately against white. Even if one weren’t familiar with Josef Albers’ experiments with color, painters do know about color’s relativity. The goal after all is to harmonize colors while creating the image. Toning a canvas in preparation for painting, or painting in the big shapes first, will both lay down that initial layer of color and set the stage for the great cover-up. What happens next is up to the individual painter.
Posted on 3/1/2016
By Donald Fox
Comment on this

An aspect of the arts that may not exactly be controversial but is often the source of disagreement because it is so difficult to be clear about is taste. If we speak of food, we know that taste is important. No one particularly enjoys something bland. We may enjoy sweet flavors but not overly so. We may even like some things that have tartness but not biting or sour. Most would enjoy something with a full, rich flavor, but even here there can be wide-ranging preference for what may be somewhat challenging to define. We like certain foods or we don’t.
I like many vegetables, for example, but I don’t like anything that is too pithy or stringy. I love both asparagus and broccoli, but each can be too tough and stringy. On those I would pass. When it comes to green beans, however, I simply will not eat them. My aversion goes back to early childhood, and while the green bean is often a staple in Southern cooking, I have never been able to acquire a taste for them.
When we use taste to express like or dislike for something other than food or drink, we speak metaphorically. Yet it is very common to say that one has a taste for good books, fine clothes, or even things unusual. Taste becomes something of a catch-all, and may often be the easy way out. One doesn’t have to be very precise or specific when expressing taste. As a result, when taste is used to suggest cultural preferences, it frequently means that good taste is in alignment with our own and bad taste is not. Discussions of taste often suggest prejudicial thinking, and this can easily lead to disagreement, miscommunication, or worse.
I enjoy many types of music and equally enjoy many kinds of visual art. I’ve tried to educate myself in areas that initially challenged me, sometimes to success where I find enjoyment when at first I did not. By moving beyond my initial prejudice, by asking questions, by learning about motivations, desires, and designs, my level of appreciation grows. There are, however, certain artistic expressions that, like my aversion to green beans, I’ve never been able to develop a taste for. I find them repulsive, inconsequential, and without redeeming value. I understand there is some cultural conditioning at work, but I just don’t like them and find myself saying or thinking that they’re distasteful.
Culturally, I think we recognize this. We have a saying, “there’s no accounting for taste.” This can be an excuse and maybe even a cop-out. Artists, I think, generally are critical thinkers, but as individuals we all have blind spots. The truly critical person will attempt to understand before outright dismissal. As said before, taste and prejudice sometimes walk hand in hand. If we can avoid offensiveness, maybe the gut response that taste often generates can be a guide. I would hope, though, that we can continue to question even some of our most ardent beliefs. Not questioning, for me, would be an example of exhibiting poor taste.
(originally published as “Taste” 4/6/12)